Advertise on ITWeb         Fri, 24 Nov, 12:54:25 PM

Multinationals in high-tax jurisdictions to benefit from relaxed IP regulations

The framework in question comprises a series of anti-avoidance provisions which were introduced to prevent erosion of the South African tax base, says Sean Gilmour, a Partner in the Tax Practice at Webber Wentzel.

Sean Gilmour, a Partner in the Tax Practice at Webber Wentzel.

Sean Gilmour, a Partner in the Tax Practice at Webber Wentzel.

The 2017 Budget announced that the regulatory framework regarding cross-border intellectual property transactions is to be relaxed, for both tax and exchange control purposes, says Sean Gilmour, a Partner in the Tax Practice at Webber Wentzel.

The framework in question comprises a series of anti-avoidance provisions which were introduced to prevent erosion of the South African tax base. The erosion of concern to National Treasury results from the assignment from South Africa of intellectual property developed in South Africa to foreign entities with a lower effective tax rate, followed by the licensing of that intellectual property back to fully taxable South African taxpayers. The royalties would, in such a scenario, remain fully deductible in South Africa but potentially subject to a low rate of tax in the jurisdiction in which the licensor is tax resident.

The current section 23I of the Income Tax Act essentially limits South African taxpayers from claiming a deduction for royalties paid to non-residents in respect of intellectual property which was originally developed in South Africa. The limitation does not apply to payments made to controlled foreign companies (CFCs) if the royalty income is fully imputed to a South African resident shareholder under the CFC provisions. The limitation which is in place is also dependent on whether the payment in question is subject to the withholding tax on royalties and if it is, at what rate.

The 2017 draft Taxation Laws Amendment Bill (DTLAB) notes concerns which arise as a result of the wide definition of "tainted intellectual property" and various interpretations of the term 'developed' in the context of "tainted intellectual property". These difficulties are noted as having a potential impact on South African based infrastructure in the context of local modifications or improvements of existing intellectual property that was not originally developed by a South African taxpayer. Section 23I may apply in a scenario in which a South African company acquires an intellectual property rich foreign subsidiary and uses South African based expertise within the group to further enhance the intellectual property.

The DTLAB proposes an exemption from the deductibility limitations and will apply if the payments are made to a CFC which is resident in a 'high tax' jurisdiction. The CFC in question must be subject to an aggregate amount of foreign tax which is at least 75% of the amount which would have been payable had the CFC been tax resident in South Africa.

The relevant definition of "tainted intellectual property" which remains unchanged is still very complex and somewhat difficult to interpret, and some refinement or clarification of this would have been welcomed. That being said, the relaxation effectively renders the provisions academic when transacting with a CFC in a high-tax jurisdiction and multinationals with operations in such jurisdictions will benefit from the proposed change.

The amendment is to come into operation on 1 January 2018 and will apply in respect of years of assessment commencing on or after that date.

Webber Wentzel

Founded in 1868, Webber Wentzel is today one of Africa's leading law firms with a total staff of approximately 800 with offices in Johannesburg and Cape Town.  Its core strategy is to support its clients wherever they do business. It is a full-service partnership with deep expertise and experience across a comprehensive range of sectors.  A deep understanding of its clients' needs and its tailored approach has led to numerous independent awards, both in South Africa and on the continent.  These include being named Africa Law Firm of the Year at the African Legal Awards Sub-Saharan Africa Legal Advisers of the Year at the European M&A Awards hosted by the Financial Times and Mergermarket, and Who's Who Legal South African Law Firm of the Year for five consecutive years. Core to the ethos of the firm is the belief that diversity is the key to delivering effective legal services in South Africa.  In harnessing the varied experiences, perspectives and backgrounds of its partners, employees and stakeholders, It ensures that it is able to serve its clients appropriately. The firm's collaborative alliance with Linklaters provides clients with market-leading support across Sub-Saharan Africa and beyond through Linklaters' Anglophone, Lusophone, Francophone and US law capability.  It also provides it with access to ad hoc international law advice on matters. Webber Wentzel's offering is further enhanced by its network of best friend law firms across Sub-Saharan Africa, and its associate membership of ALN, an integrated network of African law firms.


Editorial contacts

Webber Wentzel
Kim Jansen
Communication Manager (Internal)
(+27) 11 530 5702
This e-mail address is being protected from spambots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it


Our comments policy does not allow anonymous postings. Read the policy here




Sponsors Message