WannaCry oddities puzzle cyber security researchers
The WannaCry malware that spread to more than 100 countries in a few hours is throwing up several surprises for cyber security researchers, including how it gained its initial foothold, how it spread so fast and why the hackers are not making much money from it.
Some researchers have found evidence they say could link North Korea with the attack, but others are more cautious, saying the first step is shedding light on even the most basic questions about the malware itself.
For one thing, said IBM Security's Caleb Barlow, researchers are still unsure exactly how the malware spread in the first place. Most cyber security companies have blamed phishing e-mails ? e-mails containing malicious attachments or links to files ? that download the ransomware.
That's how most ransomware finds its way onto victims' computers.
The problem in the WannaCry case is that despite digging through the company's database of more than a billion e-mails dating back to 1 March, Barlow's team could find none linked to the attack.
"Once one victim inside a network is infected it propagates," Boston-based Barlow said in a phone interview, describing a vulnerability in Microsoft Windows that allows the worm to move from one computer to another.
The NSA used the Microsoft flaw to build a hacking tool codenamed EternalBlue that ended up in the hands of a mysterious group called the Shadow Brokers, which then published that and other such tools online.
But the puzzle is how the first person in each network was infected with the worm. "It's statistically very unusual that we'd scan and find no indicators," Barlow said.
Other researchers agree. "Right now there is no clear indication of the first compromise for WannaCry," said Budiman Tsjin of RSA Security, a part of Dell.
Knowing how malware infects and spreads is key to being able to stop existing attacks and anticipate new ones. "How the hell did this get on there, and could this be repeatedly used again?" said Barlow.
Some cyber security companies, however, say they have found a few samples of the phishing e-mails. FireEye said it was aware customers had used its reports to successfully identify some associated with the attack.
But the company agrees the malware relied less on phishing e-mails than other attacks. Once a certain number of infections was established, it was able to use the Microsoft vulnerability to propagate without their help.
There are other surprises that suggest this is not an ordinary ransomware attack.
Only paltry sums were collected by the hackers, according to available evidence, mostly in the Bitcoin cryptocurrency.
There were only three Bitcoin wallets and the campaign has so far earned only $50 000 or so, despite the widespread infections. Barlow said single payments in some other ransomware cases were more than that, depending on the victim.
Jonathan Levin of Chainalysis, which monitors Bitcoin payments, said there were other differences compared to most ransomware campaigns: for instance, the lack of sophisticated methods used in previous cases to convince victims to pay up. In the past, this has included hot lines in various languages.
And so far, Levin said, the Bitcoin that had been paid into the attackers' wallets remained there ? compared to another campaign, known as Locky, which made $15 million while regularly emptying the Bitcoin wallets.
"They really aren't set up well to handle their Bitcoin payments," Levin said.
The lack of sophistication may bolster those cyber security researchers who say they have found evidence that could link North Korea to the attack.
A senior researcher from South Korea's Hauri Labs, Simon Choi, said on Tuesday the reclusive state had been developing and testing ransomware programs only since August. In one case, the hackers demanded Bitcoin in exchange for client information they had stolen from a South Korean shopping mall.
Choi, who has done extensive research into North Korea's hacking capabilities, said his findings matched those of Symantec and Kaspersky Lab, which say some code in an earlier version of the WannaCry software had also appeared in programs used by the Lazarus, identified by some researchers as a North Korea-run hacking operation.
The Lazarus hackers have, however, been more brazen in their pursuit of financial gain than others, and have been blamed for the theft of $81 million from the Bangladesh central bank, according to some cyber security firms. The US accused it of being behind a cyber attack on Sony Pictures in 2014.
Whoever is found to be behind the attack, said Marin Ivezic, a cyber security partner at PwC in Hong Kong, the way the hackers used freely available tools so effectively may be what makes this campaign more worrying.
By bundling a tool farmed from the leaked NSA files with their own ransomware, "they achieved better distribution than anything they could have achieved in a traditional way", he said.
"EternalBlue [the hacking tool] has now demonstrated the ROI [return on investment] of the right sort of worm and this will become the focus of research for cyber criminals," Ivezic said.