Legal View

Judge allows Twitter lawsuit to move forward

Twitter says it is continuing its fight for more transparency.
Read time 1min 10sec
Twitter says it is continuing its fight for more transparency.

A US judge ruled yesterday that Twitter could move forward with a lawsuit that aims to free technology companies to speak more openly about surveillance requests they receive from the US government.

The US government had failed to show the kind of "clear and present danger" that could possibly justify restraints on Twitter's constitutional right to talk about surveillance requests, US district judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers in Oakland, California, said in a written order.

"The government's restrictions on Twitter's speech are content-based prior restraints subject to the highest level of scrutiny under the First Amendment," Rogers wrote.

The First Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees certain rights, including freedom of speech.

The US Justice Department is reviewing the decision, a spokeswoman said.

Twitter chief executive Jack Dorsey retweeted a company statement: "Twitter is continuing its fight for more transparency under the First Amendment."

Twitter filed the lawsuit in 2014 after revelations by former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden about the extent of US spying.

The lawsuit is aimed at ending legal limits on details that tech companies can provide about US national security requests. Currently, companies can reveal the number of requests they have received, but only within a range, such as 0-499 in a six-month period.

Youtube play icon