About
Subscribe

A comparison of IP telephony architectures

Johannesburg, 04 Mar 2002

When Mitel Networks identified IP telephony as the next big `technology wave` they began by understanding their customers requirements. "We commissioned an independent organisation to carry out end user research on our behalf, specifically to understand what end users expected from a next generation voice solution as well as baselining their hopes and fears," says Andy Bull, director for Mitel Networks, South Africa.

The results of the research formed the basis of Mitel`s IP product strategy. Bull discusses the key issues that were identified.

Investment Protection

Choosing a new voice solution around the time of a `technology disconnect` can be a daunting task. Early adopters will make the leap towards an IP Telephony solution but will still require support for traditional trunks and devices, like facsimile machines and analogue telephones. Those who prefer to adopt a wait and see approach need to know there is a smooth migration path to a true IP telephony architecture without making further major investments.

No Compromise

Most of the traditional PBX`s run call control software that was developed over ten years ago. Development is usually driven by customer demand, and although most users only use between 20 and 30 features, a modern PBX requires more than 500 features to satisfy the demands of many geographic regions, vertical markets as well as departments.

The traditional voice system manufacturers have also learnt a lot about reliability and desktop devices. Most have four or five telephones with optional key modules, busy lamp fields, modem interfaces etc. Operator consoles, too are also an essential part of a compete solution.

Many `next generation` IP telephony solutions have relatively new call control software with few features and may not measure up to the system they are replacing. They often have a very limited range of desktop devices with some suppliers not even being able to provide an IP operator console!

Economic Efficiencies

Industry spokespeople talk about the efficiencies of a single infrastructure and the benefits of a single skill set to administer and maintain voice, data and supporting applications. Whilst this is largely true, many hybrid solutions do not deliver on this promise. In addition, the purchase price of many true IP telephony solutions can be significantly more than a traditional PBX.

Application Delivery

IP telephony can deliver very significant advantages when it comes to deploying business solutions within an organisation. In a traditional environment `Computer Telephony Integration` (CTI) is required to link the computing and telephony infrastructure. The `narrowband pipe` and the cost of the specialist skills to implement and maintain a solution limit the deployment of applications.

In a true IP telephony environment there is no requirement for CTI as there is only one infrastructure. The `call server` is just another application on the LAN and the IP telephone is another client. Potentially any PC on the LAN has access to the `call server` and could become a telephone. Equally, the IP telephone becomes a portal into the IP network and can access any application on the network.

Bull says the research indicated users had major concerns about the commitment of some traditional PBX manufacturers. Whilst some are actively promoting their IP telephony strategy and presenting long term roadmaps, others are making relatively small investments in IP telephony to keep their existing PBX `alive`. This is particularly true for the manufacturers who have an interest in other telecommunications fields, for example mobile telephones or public exchanges.

The following IP telephony architectures are discussed in further detail by Andy Bull.

1. IP Enabled

This approach involves adding one or more IP line cards to a traditional `Time Division Multiplexed` (TDM) or `circuit switched` PBX.

  • .         Investment Protection : This is a good solution for organisations wanting to experiment with IP telephony. Adding an IP line card to an existing traditional PBX is relatively inexpensive and allows Information Technology staff to learn about the issues associated with voice over IP. However, there are two major drawbacks. Firstly, any calls leaving an individual IP line card will need to be converted back into a fixed 64 Kbps TDM signal. These unnecessary conversions from IP to TDM introduce quality of service issues. Secondly, converting back into a fixed 64 Kbps signal precludes any opportunity to deploy broadband applications such as Hi Fi voice or video telephony. Ultimately, an organisation choosing this approach will have to make a major investment in a `proper` IP telephony solution.

  • .         No Compromise : Most systems of this kind are able to deliver all the features of a traditional PBX to an IP telephone. Where IP devices are not available, for example an IP Console, a traditional device can be used.

  • .         Economic Efficiencies : In order to benefit from economic efficiencies the voice and data infrastructures need to become one. This solution does not fundamentally change administration, maintenance, cabling or application delivery. Consequently, it is unlikely to result in a lower cost of ownership.

  • .         Application Delivery : The model for application delivery continues to rely predominately on `Computer Telephony Integration`.

  • 2. IP Only

This approach implements IP telephony in a pure way. Call control is just another application on the data network.

  • .         Investment Protection : Implementing a system of this kind within an existing building often involves changing the whole infrastructure and most, if not all of the devices. Support for existing analogue devices and traditional trunks is often very limited and involves the use of an analogue to IP conversion box. These are expensive and make unnecessary conversions that introduce quality of service issues. For example, a call is made from a facsimile machine to an ISDN trunk. The call is then converted from a circuit switched signal to IP and back to circuit switched signal as it leaves the system. This could happen at the terminal end, resulting in a total of four conversions - for an analogue to analogue call!!

  • .         No Compromise : The call control often has few features and may not be the equal of the system it replaces. In addition, the range of IP devices may be limited and this is usually a major concern for a system manager. Taking features away from telephone users can be extremely unpopular. However, one way of resolving this is to retain a traditional PBX (shown above) but integration between the two systems can be limited and the expense of maintaining two systems negates many of the advantages.

  • .         Economic Efficiencies : Voice and data skills are largely common and the cabling infrastructure is usually simplified. Access to administration and maintenance is usually web based.

  • .         Application Delivery : The `call server` is just another application on the LAN and the IP telephones are another client on the LAN. Potentially any PC on the LAN has access to the `call server` and could become a telephone. Equally, the IP telephone becomes a portal into the IP network and can access any application on the network. This vastly simplifies the application delivery model.

  • 3. IP Plus

This approach combines the benefits of the IP enabled and IP only architectures. The system contains both an IP core and a TDM backbone. Calls made from a traditional device to a traditional trunk, for example an ISDN trunk is switched directly across the TDM backbone. For calls made between two IP telephones, the system acts as a call server. Voice packets between the two IP telephones travel directly across the LAN between the telephones. This is the approach Mitel has adopted.

  • .         Investment Protection : The system should have the option to be configured as an all `circuit switched` voice system or an all IP telephony system. In each case it implements the solution properly. In addition, the system can support a blend of both. This allows a predominately IP telephony system to support some legacy devices. It also allows organisations to move to IP telephony at their own pace.

  • .         No Compromise : Choose a supplier who has an abundance of IP telephony desktop devices available including key module / busy lamp fields, audio conference units and a PC based operator console.

  • .         Economic Efficiencies : Ensure the IP telephone includes an IP data port allowing an IP device, such as a desktop PC, to be connected to the telephone. This dramatically reduces the requirement for data switch ports and cabling. When a user relocates to another desk, an IP telephone can simply be unplugged and moved. This virtually eliminates the requirement for administration changes

  • .         Application Delivery : In an IP environment, the `call server` is just another application on the LAN and the IP telephones are another client on the LAN. The IP telephone becomes a portal into the IP network and can access any application on the network. For example, a Web telephone can display company broadcasts or information downloaded from a server about a caller. Soon IP telephones will be able to support Hi Fi quality telephony and even video images!

Share

Mitel Networks

Mitel Networks is a market-leader for voice, video, and data convergence over broadband networks. With a focus on the user experience, the company delivers advanced communications solutions that are easily customised for individual business needs. Through intuitive desktop appliances and applications, businesses are provided with innovative ways to manage information and resources. Vertical markets benefit from integrated solutions that protect existing investments while enabling new ways to be more cost effective and productive. With over 30 years of expertise, the company is delivering a new, more simplified form of convergence, with clear benefits to the end user. Mitel Networks is headquartered in Ottawa, Canada with offices, partners, and resellers worldwide. For more information please visit www.mitel.com

Editorial contacts

Alison Bull
Alison Bull Communications
(011) 783 0594
abcomms@iafrica.com