About
Subscribe

Barry leaves Telkom with confidence, gloom

Johannesburg, 04 Jul 2002

Tom Barry, the outspoken and often controversial chief operating officer of Telkom, will leave the company and the telecommunications industry on Friday after stints of 34 years and four years respectively.

As the main local representative of 30% Telkom stakeholder Thintana, the joint venture between his American employer SBC and Telekom Malaysia, Barry often found himself under fire. But he gave as good as he got (better, some would say) with criticism of the government, regulators, the competition and often Telkom itself.

At the end of next week, Shawn McKenzie, an SBC president from Texas who is 15 years his junior, will take his vacated position.

Barry says he still finds excitement and challenges in his work, but has vowed not to even become involved in political lobbying when he retires to Washington.

"This is my last paid-for job," he says.

And although he intends to follow Telkom`s future from afar, he does not expect to speculate about what his successor will get up to.

"There is nothing broken so nothing needs to be fixed, but nothing is perfect so everything needs to be worked on," he says of the situation McKenzie will find when he arrives in the country today.

As for the company as a whole, his only concern is that key members of the management team could leave.

"If we had two or three defections, for any reason, there could be problems," he says. "We don`t have a huge surplus of trained and experienced management in SA."

However, he believes the pay packages offered to all Telkom employees are attractive, and the addition of share options after the company lists will make them even more so.

Despite his faith in the company, which this week reported a profit of nearly R2 billion, he cannot guarantee that Thintana will not get rid of its 30% shareholding soon after Telkom is listed, as government, the majority owner, intends to do before the end of the fiscal year. SBC last week announced that it would sell a fifth of its stake in a Canadian operator for $870 million, with an option to sell the rest, in order to reduce its own debt. Barry says there is no intention to sell out of Telkom but that any responsible company "always keeps its options open".

Predictions of monopoly

Potential Telkom investors may be skittish because of the imminent introduction of a competitor, the second national operator (SNO) in which Eskom and Transtel are so far the only players. Barry sees little chance for long-term success for a competitor, or for a third cellular operator such as Cell C for that matter. He says four decades of observation leads him to believe that telecommunications is a natural monopoly.

"The evidence in the last 18 to 24 months is tending to suggest that my hypothesis is correct. You see sophisticated companies spending trillions trying to prove that it is not a natural monopoly, but I think the evidence is pilling up."

He argues that duplicating infrastructure, as the SNO is intended to do in part, is an obvious mistake. "The cost of starting a telecoms company is just about incomprehensible. By definition, if you are in a natural monopoly you will dominate the market because you are the only one in a society with the resources to invest."

Telkom has spent nearly R50 billion on its infrastructure in the past five years.

Barry blames much of the current woes of American markets on "experimentation" around the monopoly idea, saying the ripple effect from problems at Lucent, Nortel and WorldCom "are enormous". SA, he suggests, does not have the resources to absorb failure from similar experiments.

Yet he has no doubt that consumers can look forward to cheap telecommunications in SA. Within the next five years, he predicts, affluent and urban citizens will have "virtually anything they like at reasonable prices" - as long as they can pay for it.

"The backbone infrastructure has sort of gotten ahead of the economy and that was sort of the point anyway."

IPO value

Barry says he is not about to sever all ties with SA; he plans to offer his services to the SA Embassy in Washington and is already planning American fundraising for charities such as an Aids orphanage in KwaZulu-Natal.

He will probably try not to keep a very close look at the Telkom share price once it is listed. Over the five-year exclusivity period that expired in May this year, the intrinsic value of Telkom increased significantly, he says, but that is not likely to be recognised.

"The company is in great shape, the market is in terrible shape."

Related stories:
Telkom, Thintana bewildered by government

Share