About
Subscribe
  • Home
  • /
  • Telecoms
  • /
  • Constitutional challenge could delay Telkom listing

Constitutional challenge could delay Telkom listing

Phillip de Wet
By Phillip de Wet, ITWeb contributor
Johannesburg, 04 Dec 2002

A legal challenge could delay the listing of Telkom, due before the end of February next year, as the courts try to determine when discrimination is fair.

Trade union group Solidarity, described by some as right-of-centre, plans to ask the courts to stop the process of individuals and groups registering their interest in buying shares in Telkom. It believes the Khulisa scheme, which is to offer the chance to buy discounted shares, is unconstitutional.

Under Khulisa, individuals and groups such as stokvels will be offered Telkom shares at a greater discount than the general offer. The cost of share dealings is also to be subsidised and those who hold their Khulisa shares for more than two years are to receive one free share for every five held.

However, the Khulisa shares are to be held in an independently administered trust for two years and those taking up the offer will be barred from selling their shares for the first three months after listing.

Khulisa was to be open only to historically disadvantaged individuals, but yesterday the Department of Public Enterprises issued a statement saying it will now be opened to all South Africans. However, it said the previously disadvantaged would be given preferential access to the scheme, leaving the net effect unchanged.

The change in was apparently triggered by Solidarity expressing its intention to challenge the constitutionality of Khulisa, but has not succeeded in deflecting the trade group.

Affirmative action and black empowerment schemes are protected under section 9 (2) of the Constitution, which states that "to promote the achievement of equality, legislative and other measures designed to protect or advance persons, or categories of persons, disadvantaged by unfair discrimination may be taken".

Solidarity spokesman Kallie Kriel says the group agrees that past imbalances must be rectified but believes the Khulisa offer will not do so.

"Will selling shares to black people at a discount promote equality? No. What you`ll have is black millionaires buying shares cheaply and profiting, while people from another race group, even if they are jobless, will not benefit. Meanwhile the poorest of the poor in the black community will not be able to afford shares anyway."

Kriel says that such a failure removes the granted by the Constitution and makes the discrimination applied unfair.

Solidarity is pushing for the criteria for Khulisa to be changed to income rather than race. Anyone earning less than R5 000 a month should qualify, it argues, which would include much of the black population without racial discrimination.

"It comes down to having two lines for people buying bread, and those of a certain racial group gets theirs cheaper," he says.

Solidarity plans to launch an urgent application to stop the registration process within days and, if a court order is granted, argue for changes to the offer.

However, Kriel says the group has no problem with the Telkom listing in general and does not want to delay the process. A process is under way to start discussions between Solidarity and the Department of Public Enterprise.

However, further changes to the share offer seem unlikely. According to those close to the process, the constitutionality of the offer was examined, along with other legal implications, more than a year ago and no legal difficulties were foreseen at the time.

Solidarity, created in 2001 by the amalgamation of the Mine Workers Union with several other groups, claims a membership of well over 100 000 and is one of three trade unions represented in Telkom.

Related stories:
Registration for Telkom shares opens

Share