About
Subscribe

Disclosing your secrets

The "father of the firewall", Marcus Ranum, on the issues surrounding the disclosure of security problems.
By Laurika Bretherton, ITWeb Chicago-based correspondent
Chicago, 14 Nov 2000

The "father of the firewall", Marcus Ranum opened the 27th annual Computer Conference in Chicago this week. Ranum, who built the first commercial firewall in 1989, focused his presentation on the issues surrounding the disclosure of security problems.

"Most of the disclosure of security problems that are made public by hackers are done so in order to market their skills and help them establish a track record

Marcus Ranum,

He listed the three players in the current disclosure economy: hackers, vendors and end-users. "Each one of these groups has its own agenda and requires the use of different sets of carrots and sticks."

He talked about the hacking community first and listed its main carrot as visibility. "Most of the disclosure of security problems that are made public by hackers are done so in order to market their skills and help them establish a track record.

"Their sticks are liability or the potential for liability. Hackers have to begin to take responsibility for their actions and realise they could be tagged with a negative reputation that could come back and haunt them one day."

Ranum said that the carrots for vendors are sales and a positive market image. "If you say to the average vendor that their sales will increase by 10% if they do this specific thing, you have their undivided attention. Vendors also like being told they will be seen as market leaders. That`s another attention grabber."

The simplest sticks for vendors are the prevention of sales and the potential of embarrassment, according to Ranum.

"Users also have their carrots. They are software that works better and software that gives them less exposure to hacking attacks. Their sticks are less reliable systems and an increased chance of being hacked."

Ranum argued that in the current economy of security disclosures, what is good for the hacker is usually bad for the vendor and vice versa. He believes the answer lies in redefining the concept and rewriting the rules of security disclosure.

"We need to provide all players with adequate carrots and sticks. What we`re missing is a vendor neutral third-party who will keep a public readable Web site that keeps scores of how many positive and negative points both vendors and hackers have. This Web site should have an income that does not relate to any vendor advertising. It needs to find its method of making money in some other way.

"We can also bring in an audit firm that can give a vendor a black mark if they don`t qualify and we can start barring those hackers with black marks from getting employment."

Share