About
Subscribe
  • Home
  • /
  • Telecoms
  • /
  • Myths undermine realities of SA`s telecoms sector, says 1997 Communication Technologies Handbook

Myths undermine realities of SA`s telecoms sector, says 1997 Communication Technologies Handbook

Johannesburg, 06 Jun 1996

The global telecommunications community is in the throes of the largest technology industry and market dislocation ever experienced, according to the latest (1997) edition of the Communication Technologies Handbook published by BMI-TechKnowledge (BMI-T), the leading South African market research company covering the telecommunications, information technology and electronics industries.

The Handbook provides detailed information on telecomms and networking infrastructure throughout Africa. Priced at R1 400 per copy, it comprises more than 400 pages focusing on key aspects of communications technology and the business issues behind it.

Included are the results of primary market research conducted in 15 African countries, and it features a host of graphs and tables to illustrate statistical information. Contributors include such leading figures as Minister of Posts, Telecommunications and Broadcasting Jay Naidoo, International Telecommunications Union Secretary General Dr Pekka Tarjanne and ITU Telecommunication Development Bureau Director Ahmed Laouyane.

This worldwide tumult has profound implications for SA, says the Handbook, which is based on original market research and provides detailed information on infrastructure, traffic trends, market structure and growth, key indicators, policy and regulatory issues, and the telecomms supply industry. As well as profiling the state of telecomms in SA, the Handbook covers 14 other African countries in depth.

In a chapter headed "South Africa - The Next Few Years", BMI-T managing director Denis Smit argues that perhaps the most important change in the last 10 years has been the increasing understanding by governments and their agencies that telecomms plays a significantly larger role in economic growth than previously believed.

"Progressive governments have realised that telecomms is not only a vibrant industry in itself and thus a lucrative source of revenue, but that its impact on other sectors of the economy can be substantial. Governments that previously believed they had only monetary and fiscal policy instruments to manage their economies are increasingly aware that telecomms policy itself can play an influential, even decisive, role in economic growth."

"Telecommunications, if properly deployed and regulated, can stimulate the economy without stimulating inflation. This is an economist`s Nirvana, as growth without inflation translates into real wealth for the people but it happens only when regulators ensure that telecomms services are delivered to customers at drastically reducing prices."

The advent of the wired consumer is the single most important market paradigm shift that the world has faced for many decades, perhaps centuries, argues Smit. "The razor which economists use to determine key success factors, comparative advantage, has shifted from natural causes, such as climate and geography, to man-made causes - cheap telecomms, literacy, innovative capacity. "Because of the isolation resulting from apartheid, SA has lagged far behind international developments.

The 1996 Telecommunications Act, BMI-T believes, is more aligned with the stated aims of the Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) than with that of the GEAR (Growth, Employment and Redistribution) macro-economic strategy, which is economic growth. Consequently it is BMI-T`s opinion that the SA market and industry are still unduly influenced by a number of popular myths which need to be challenged.

Telecommunications is a natural monopoly - a natural asset to be protected from competition to fulfill its mission to provide universal service through centrally co-ordinated allocation of scarce resources. This may have been true 10 years ago, but is not so any more, writes Smit.

"By next year the situation for monopolists will have worsened considerably and this will continue for decades. New technologies and new cost structures, especially in wireless communications, have made the old-style monopolies obsolete. The myth above is merely operators` propaganda to persuade governments to keep filling their exclusive trough.

"The national network is a valuable asset that needs proper management and enhancement. Network operators, especially landline operators, face the stark reality that the cost of installing bandwidth is coming down so fast and the demand for additional bandwidth is so huge that new emerging technologies and customer-focused value-added services will devastate traditional revenue flows.

BMI-T is of the opinion that a skillful balance of regulatory control and a rapid introduction of competition is needed. Incumbent operators need to be exposed sooner rather than later to full legal competition - such competition, legal or not, is inevitable. With newer, more cost effective technologies and improved world-class management systems, Telkom can play leap-frog. SA can, if policy makers and regulators allow, become as successful, if not more so, than Mexico in raising teledensity.

Liberalisation of telecommunications destroys jobs. This debate has hinged largely on flawed thinking, argues Smit. The reality worldwide is that telecommunications creates jobs. Jobs may be lost as operators downsize to become more cost-effective, but more jobs are created as competitors move into the market.

The real issue is not the protection of union jobs but the retraining of telecomms employees for new roles. Unless there is a fundamental commitment by all stakeholders to develop the people already in the sector the information age will be still-born.

It will go according to plan. "Does it ever?" he asks. "Without being cynical, the reality is that most important telecomms decisions are made by people far removed from SA. To believe that South Africans control the destiny of the local telecomms sector is an illusion, perhaps a dangerous one.

"Harold Wilson once said a week is a long time in politics. Six years in a high-tech industry is an eternity, let alone the 25 for which the Act gives Telkom a licence. Technology and market forces will strain a regulatory framework past breaking point if it is inflexible. And, if the government is serious about creating jobs, it may be forced to deregulate fast to kick-start the economy. One such measure could be the acceleration of competition to Telkom - the approach taken by many other governments worldwide.

Telkom will crumble under competition. Firstly, this belies Telkom management`s track record. Secondly, there is no precedent for a former monopoly carrier losing more than 5% to 15% of the market. Usually the market has grown much more, leaving the former monopoly better off financially.

Thirdly, the former monopolies tend to gain market share as markets mature. The crucial issue is that the new competitors will increase the size of the entire market so that even if Telkom does lose market share it will still dominate a much larger market. "The period facing the SA telecomms sector now will have a big and lasting positive effect on the whole economy," argues Smit.

"If managed well, this massive growth will be leveraged into other sectors, thereby ensuring a direct and tangible contribution to the national economy and welfare of all the country`s citizens." The Handbook sells for R1 400 a copy (including VAT) and is available from the publishers.

Share

Editorial contacts

Cheryl Smith
BMI-TechKnowledge
(011) 803 6412
cheryl@bmi-t.co.za