Two industry organisations have taken the government's director-general of communications Andile Ngcaba to task for choosing to ignore "rebellious" behaviour by the South African Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (SATRA) and likening it to the last spasm of a dying horse.
"Anarchy is one step away," says Adrian Schofield, president of the Information Industry of South Africa (IISA) umbrella body, which includes the Black IT Forum, the Computer Society of South Africa and the IT Association, among others.
Ngcaba has said that his department and the ministry would not respond to SATRA's decision to implement its interconnection and facility leasing guidelines, likening the resolution to "the manifestation of the last kicks of a dying horse".
"It is simply not good enough that government should ignore the statutory authority specifically set up to ensure administrative fairness and justice," Schofield says in a IISA statement. The association says it is unacceptable for the director-general to undermine an institution of state.
The South African Value-Added Network Services Association (SAVA) says it is unhappy with the current situation, as it was unhappy with the withdrawal of the regulations. SAVA is a member of the IISA. "This raises all sorts of questions," says SAVA chairman Mike van den Bergh. "Comments from the [director-general] calling into question the integrity of what is in essence an organ of state is unacceptable."
SAVA's complaint against Telkom for its withholding of services was heard before SATRA this week, and Van den Bergh says the guidelines would make such disputes easier to handle.
"Look, the guidelines were not perfect, but they were certain," he says. "That is what we needed."
Van den Bergh notes that SAVA is still not satisfied with any of the reasons given for the attempted withdrawal of the guidelines after they were published. He believes that if the document contained errors it should never have been published and considers two years of public consultation to be sufficient. But most troubling to Van den Bergh is the third reason, put forward by Ngcaba himself. "The justification that SATRA is to be disbanded soon and the regulations had to be withdrawn because of that bothers me the most," he says. "The implication is that the new authority [ICASA] will be tamer than the last one."
Schofield and Van den Bergh agree in their private capacities that merging the Independent Broadcast Authority and SATRA is not necessarily a step in the right direction. "Personally, I think it is better to have regulation of content and regulation of the means of transmission separate," says Schofield. "Now the technical side and the philosophy of content will be combined."
Van den Bergh says the merger may have been rushed for the wrong reasons. "I wonder if it wasn't done too early as a way of sorting out the problems at SATRA."
Related stories:
Department to ignore SATRA's decision
SATRA opts to ignore minister

