About
Subscribe

SDN, Telkom battle it out in court

Staff Writer
By Staff Writer, ITWeb
Johannesburg, 24 Feb 2000

In the early hours of Thursday morning, Telkom started disconnecting the lines of Satellite Networks (SDN) "following the non-payment of outstanding accounts amounting to several million rand".

The matter was in court before the sun came up, and by the close of business on Thursday, SDN claimed a moral victory. But that victory is temporary and limited.

Telkom says SDN owes it several million rand. SDN says it owes no money, because it doesn't want or need the service it is being charged for.

The service in question is Teleport, an asymmetrical satellite service with transmission dishes at Telkom sites and bandwidth backhaul to the customer. Telkom has been charging SDN R3 million per month for the service since making it available at the end of November last year.

SDN says Telkom is playing dirty. "Telkom's actions are an attempt to force a commercial resolution to the failed negotiations between Telkom and SDN over recent months regarding a broader dispute," says SDN joint MD Nalen Padiachy.

SDN uses its own transmission dish located at its offices in Johannesburg, linking to a first tier carrier in the US via Intelsat.

Both Telkom and SDN have confirmed that the Teleport issue is awaiting a ruling by the South African Telecommunications Authority (SATRA). Telkom corporate communications executive Zeona Motshabi admits that Teleport is peripherally involved with the suspension of service, but says the decision to cut circuits was based on non-payment only.

In a statement, SDN quotes a letter from Telkom with regards to the suspension dated 23 February giving a pre-condition of restoration as "a commercial agreement to be concluded between Telkom and SDN pertaining to the relocation of the telecommunication services to Telkom's Teleport sites".

Joint SDN MD Antony Stafford says Telkom moved aggressively because of pressure from competing service providers to provide them with similar services. He says the competition believes Telkom has conferred an unfair advantage on SDN. "In fact, at least one court application has been made by the Internet Solution (IS) in this regard." Stafford also says IS attempted to acquire SDN "due to the impact we had in the market," and when that failed went to court citing SDN as second respondent.

IS could not immediately be reached for comment.

Meanwhile, Telkom proceeded to suspend SDN services during Wednesday night and early Thursday morning. SDN made an urgent application in the Johannesburg courts for its lines to be re-connected. That application was granted and the court ordered Telkom to reinstate service. But Telkom took the matter back to the courts, arguing that the Johannesburg court did not have jurisdiction over the matter. Jurisdiction was settled when the High Court affirmed the decision, and SDN claimed victory in round one.

But Telkom says the order to restore service in Johannesburg does not apply in the rest of the country. "We can still remove services in other parts of the country," Motshabi says.

By 5.30pm on Thursday, Telkom had complied with the order and SDN said service had been restored to most of its users. "98% of our customers are up," said Stafford. At the time, SDN was contemplating further legal action based on the result of Telkom's action. "We have yet to lose any customers, our client base is behind us," Stafford responded to a question. "We believe there will be clients lost later, and we will take action against the relevant parties."

Telkom has indicated that it will take action of its own. "Due to SDN's erratic payment patterns, Telkom is also demanding that a deposit be lodged and that all outstanding amounts be paid before the suspended services are restored," read the statement that Telkom issued as notification of the suspension.

Related stories:

SDN service cut

Share