The International Cricket Council (ICC) Champions Trophy, which is under way in Sri Lanka, has once again pitted techno-adventists against sports traditionalists and romantics, following an ICC decision to experiment further with the third umpire.
Previously, third umpires could use technology only to rule on run-outs, stumpings and whether a ball had crossed the boundary. To that list has now been added a host of other possibilities, including leg before wicket (lbw) and bat-pad catches.
The third umpire can study two TV replays before giving his verdict, although he is expected to do this within about 40 seconds, in order not to slow the game down too much.
History was made last Thursday when Pakistan`s Shoaib Malik became the first batsman to be ruled out lbw by the third umpire during his team`s clash with the host nation.
The use of technology as an aid to decision-making by officials has long been controversial, although it is certainly beginning to make its presence felt in a number of major sports.
Electronic eyes and cameras have been in use in some sports for a number of years, to good effect. These include horseracing, from which the phrase "photo finish" has since been coined, and tennis, where electronic eyes assist umpires in making net and line calls.
Recently, other sports have begun adopting - or at least calling for experimentation with - various technologies.
Rugby has embraced the concept of a "tele-ref", to help referees decide on contentious tries, although that is the only area where the camera can be brought in. It is not yet available for any other refereeing decisions, such as sending a player off. There have been calls to expand its use, although just as many oppose it. Opponents fear more use of the tele-ref will slow the game down.
Football is another major sport that has been the focus of those who are in favour of introducing technology into the sporting arena.
During the recent World Cup in South Korea and Japan, a number of controversial decisions resulted in several of the major soccer super powers being eliminated early. Since then, calls have been made to introduce some form of television referee to aid with penalty and goal line decisions, although football`s world governing body, FIFA, has so far strongly resisted any move in this direction.
Cricket has used the third umpire concept to good effect for several years, and based on this track record, the ICC has now decided to experiment with an expanded role, which nonetheless takes into account the limitations of the technology.
One area where television has proven limitations is with catches close to the ground. Even with super-slow replays it is often impossible to tell whether the ball has touched the ground, so the ICC still wants field umpires to be the sole judge of whether such catches are cleanly taken.
Reuters reports that SA, the pioneer in the use of the third umpire technology, has welcomed the decision to experiment with it further.
Captain Shaun Pollock says: "At some stage we have to try it and see how well it works. From the players` perspectives we want to see the best decisions made and if technology can do that without taking too much time, I`m all for it. This is a good chance to find out."
Australian captain Ricky Ponting disagreed, saying his main concern was how much time it would take to refer decisions back to the third umpire, because a run-out decision now takes the TV umpire one to two minutes.
West Indies captain Carl Hooper was also not too optimistic, stating: "In lbw decisions, I want umpires to have a say. I hate to see umpires being pushed to one side. We should not be totally dependent on technology."
However, New Zealand captain Stephen Fleming feels that it is in the interests of the game to give it a try. "This is the opportune time to try it out before the World Cup and we hope it goes well, adding another dimension to the game."
ICC chief executive Malcolm Speed said: "The ICC is going about it with an open mind. We don`t want to turn umpires into robots; we are only offering the best use of technology to assist them in their decision-making.
"Everyone wants to see the right decisions being made. This is just a test, it is not an absolute. If it is not successful, we will discontinue it."

