Business Intelligence solutions companies Cognos and Business Objects (BO) have reached a $24 million settlement in a patent infringement lawsuit.
Business Objects filed a lawsuit in the US in 2000, alleging that Cognos Impromptu software infringed on its US patent.
Cognos maintains that the patent is invalid and unenforceable, but says it agreed to pay a $24 million settlement to avoid a protracted legal battle.
In terms of the agreement, BO releases Cognos from any alleged infringement of this patent. Cognos will license rights to the patent from BO, with the licence covering both past and future technology. Both sides have also agreed to a five-year moratorium on patent litigation between the companies.
Cognos CEO Ron Zambonini emphasises that the settlement is no admission on the validity, enforceability or infringement of any patent. He says Cognos was prepared to go to court with a strong case, but the opportunity for a settlement arose during a pre-trial meeting.
"By resolving this matter now, we avoid the distraction of continued litigation and eliminate the risk of an uncertain jury verdict and any subsequent appeals," he said. "We are very pleased to have this issue behind us and now look forward to devoting all of our time and efforts towards delivering the world`s leading business intelligence solutions to our customers."
Business Objects CEO Bernard Liautaud says the settlement recognises the value of BO-patented technology. "In 1990, Business Objects invented a new query paradigm, using a semantic layer that allowed business users to access relational databases by insulating them from the complexity of database structures," he says. "This invention has been key to the growth and success of Business Objects and we believe it changed the business intelligence industry altogether."
BO says this is the second time it has successfully enforced this patent. In January 1997, the company filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Brio Software, later reaching a $10 million settlement.
Related press releases:
BO to receive $24m from Cognos in patent settlement
Cognos settles patent litigation

