Both CommuniTel and Two Consortium - as well as market analyst BMI-TechKnowledge - are confident that the minister`s announcement on the way forward for the second national operator (SNO) will prove to be successful.
Yesterday, communications minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri announced that the 51% share will be warehoused until a suitable investor is found, while a licence will be issued to the entity that consists of the integrated 30% of the state-owned enterprises, the 19% held by Nexus Connexion and the warehoused 51% stake.
She also indicated that an equity partner for the 51% stake could be known within the next eight weeks.
BMI-T`s director of research, Brian Nielson, says the company is cautiously optimistic, despite the fact that there remain a few sceptics who would question whether the process would progress smoothly from this point.
"A number of questions remain unanswered, in particular, who the 51% investors will be, and there could still be considerable legal wrangling over this matter," he says.
"It all depends on how involved the two losing bidders are in the consortium that is ultimately awarded the SEP share."
Positive outlook
Two Consortium`s chairman, Dr Kwame Amuah, says the organisation`s view is a positive one, and he believes the minister`s announcement indicates that there is a process under way for creating an SNO that will be able to mount a viable challenge to Telkom.
"We are certainly still going to participate in the process, as we feel we definitely have a part to play. After all, two of our major shareholders have already been awarded licences in other regions, and if they are good enough to operate in places like South America and Europe, why not in Africa?" he says.
Amuah says there is a possibility of Two working with CommuniTel in moving the process forward, and the two organisations have already held informal discussions at various stages of the SNO process.
"If that is where the process takes us, we will certainly consider that option, although as a caveat I must also say that it takes two to tango, so it would have to be a genuine joint effort.
"Personally, I would not have a problem with such a development, but of course, it would ultimately be something our shareholders would have to decide on."
Speedy resolution?
Peter Archer, CEO of CommuniTel, says the minister`s decision can be viewed in a number of different ways.
"We are taking a positive view of this development and we are looking forward to starting negotiations with the government and other interested parties very soon," says Archer.
"The minister`s decision certainly indicates the potential for a speedy resolution to the SNO process, so we are certainly not going to knock it."
Nielson says BMI-T believes the new consortium may well include more direct involvement from major telecoms operators, rather than the arms-length involvement previously envisaged in the bid documents.
"Two Consortium has already suggested a non-shareholding relationship with MTN and we believe there is a chance they could form part of the new consortium," he says.
"This makes sense in the light of the convergence trend, and it would also make sense for MTN and the SNO to combine on a more formal level, although this would obviously depend on the cellular provider`s appetite for what is potentially a less lucrative business."
Related stories:
51% SNO shareholder in eight weeks
SNO`s window of opportunity is shrinking
SNO follows third cell licence`s rocky path

