About
Subscribe
  • Home
  • /
  • Security
  • /
  • Companies discover who is the weakest link in their IT security

Companies discover who is the weakest link in their IT security

Worldwide survey shows average loss of $108 000 per incident
Johannesburg, 10 Apr 2002

KPMG`s first global information security survey shows that there are significant differences in protection among large firms, both geographically and between organisations. Security incidents cost companies millions of dollars every year and average $108 000 per incident, but most companies are over-confident to the point of complacency about their security measures.

The South African respondents indicated that the average cost of a security incident was $52 223.

Key findings:

New technology poses new threats - 43% of firms were implementing or planning to implement a wireless network - but over a third using these networks do not protect them, leading to the new phenomenon of "drive-by hacking". Some 43% of firms allow staff to connect PDAs - with many actively encouraging this practice. But only 20% of those permitting use had, or were planning to implement, control software.

Our survey in SA indicates that 50% of respondents allowed staff to connect PDAs - only 16% of these have, or are planning to implement, control software.

Large amounts are spent on IT security - average spend on IT security among respondents was $2.6 million - representing 10% of overall IT budgets.

The South African average spend on information security for 2001 was $496 000, representing 11% of IT budgets.

There is a difference between companies` perception of threats and actual security breaches. Companies thought viruses and hackers posed the equal greatest security threats. This is true for virus incidents with over 60% of respondents claiming a significant incident in the past year. However, the second most common security problem was simple low-tech theft of IT equipment - reported by 38% of sample and averaging almost $100 000 per incident.

In SA, 63% of companies that responded had experienced theft of IT equipment in the last year, which is significantly higher than the global average. The average cost in SA for theft of IT equipment was $16 331.

Even those most confident of their security systems were vulnerable - 58% of respondents were adamant they were taking all reasonable steps to protect themselves, yet among this group 10% had no way of measuring the effectiveness of their security measures because they had no way of testing them, 52% had no way of knowing they were being hacked until too late, with almost all admitting they had suffered some sort of external attack in the past year.

Firms are unable to tell how well they are doing in terms of security performance - with over half unaware of how much they were spending on information security. Some 40% had no form of security violation reporting and only 35% measured and reported security performance.

These averages were very similar in SA.

Governance is lacking - less than 50% of organisations had board level responsibility for information security, while 73% of security staff have no formal qualifications.

While the board level representation in SA is similar to the global average, our survey found that 80% of information security staff had no formal information security qualifications.

Commentary

Stated losses are undoubtedly an under-estimate and can be realistically doubled by the cost impact of downtime, reduced employee productivity and post event security measures, as well as possibly significant long-term reputational damage. However, the extent of unreported or unmeasured breaches would indicate that these costs are merely the tip of an iceberg.

A large number of companies are still reluctant to discipline staff who commit breaches, or prosecute third-parties - possibly for fear of damage to reputation.

Many organisations still see security as a technical issue residing in the IT department. Yet many of the common security breaches are caused not by technology, but people. People write down passwords, they forget to examine security settings after upgrading systems. Without board level commitment, security will always be seen as a technology issue and not given the necessary resources and attention to ensure that risks are effectively minimised.

Levels of security were noticeably weaker in the Asia Pacific area, presenting problems for multinational companies operating integrated IT systems. The financial services sector was significantly better protected in a number of key areas and as a result, had a significantly lower level of security breaches.

Companies` security policies covered areas where there has been most concern and damage in recent years - such as Internet, viruses, data protection and privacy. The areas which were least covered are those most likely to cause concern in the future - security of information held on PDAs, incident reporting and escalation and information classification.

Commenting on the survey, Frank Rizzo, Information Security Partner at KPMG, said: "Measuring security performance is a growing area of concern. If you can`t measure something, then you can`t manage it effectively. Our survey shows that companies are lacking in ability to measure and report on security performance.

"Organisations also have to look for their weakest link. In the world of e-business and extended enterprises there are no effective geographical and organisational boundaries. If levels of Internet protection are not applied equally and everywhere, the weakest link will expose all others in the chain to attack."

Share

Editorial contacts

Frank Rizzo
KPMG
(011) 647 7388