About
Subscribe

Expedient process may adversely affect SNO

Rodney Weidemann
By Rodney Weidemann, ITWeb Contributor
Johannesburg, 20 May 2003

The current process for awarding the second operator (SNO) licence has sacrificed transparency for the sake of expedience, and this could adversely affect the entire process, according to a local telecoms analyst.

Andre Wills, a founding member of Africa Analysis, says that while the original SNO licensing process was much more time-intensive, it was nonetheless transparent, whereas the current set-up is focused on expedience, which could lead to problems later in the process.

"Expedience by its very nature means cutting corners, and if short cuts are taken in the SNO process, it will leave the government open to the kind of potential court cases we witnessed during the licensing of the third cellular operator," says Wills.

"Also, since the process takes place behind closed doors, the potential exists for the other players in the licence - Esi-Tel and Nexus - to have a far bigger say in which of the consortiums is eventually awarded the licence."

He says another big issue is that the SNO working committee has already stated that it is prepared to combine the best parts of several bids into one so-called "super bid".

"The problem here is how do you equitably split the 51% stake among these segments of the different bidder`s operations, and who exactly decides what the criteria are by which the percentages of the stake are awarded?" asks Wills.

"Then there is the issue of confidentiality clauses. The SNO working committee will have to be that during these 'super bid` negotiations, they can easily prejudice one of the bidders by revealing too much information during the negotiations, which could again lead to legal action."

Wills also believes that at least some of the present bidders for the licence are chancing their luck, in the hopes that they will be absorbed into the "super bid".

He says that for these bidders, who do not necessarily have all four key aspects required for the licence - namely a management team, empowerment segment, financial backing and an international operator - only a small percentage of the total stake would be considered a win, as the SNO promises to be quite a money-spinner.

"They have everything to gain and practically nothing to lose. Of course, the bidders who have submitted comprehensive plans can conversely only lose out, as they may find the SNO committee wants to replace - for example - their financial segment with one from another bid.

"The problem is that this could lead to court cases from within the consortium, depending on the contracts between partners, and the SNO will be useless if the licensee ends up having to play referee to its own shareholders for the first year or so."

This sort of legal problem would also play into Telkom`s hands, giving the incumbent operator more time to refine its services and entrench its market position.

"A lot of people will be frustrated by the ongoing SNO saga and will rather go with an operator that already has structures in place and which has quantifiable service levels," he says.

"How many people will then switch to an untried and untested operator when it finally begins operations, as opposed to how many will simply find it easier to remain with Telkom?"

In other words, we are still a long way from achieving the SNO and the process we have chosen to get there is one that is fraught with potential problems.

"In a nutshell, what we have done is taken the bidding process, stuck it inside Pandora`s Box, shut the lid and shaken it up. Now we are waiting to see just what exactly is going to come out."

Related stories:
Four bids short-listed for SNO licence
New SNO process raises too many questions
SNO process hits crucial stage

Share