About
Subscribe

Expert slams new SNO process

Rodney Weidemann
By Rodney Weidemann, ITWeb Contributor
Johannesburg, 04 Mar 2003

Communications minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri`s decision to pursue a process of "confidential negotiations" with potential foreign SNO investors was slammed by a telecommunications expert at a recent combined Communications Users Association of South Africa (CUASA) and South African Value-Added Association (SAVA) meeting.

Professor William Melody, former chief economist of the US Federal Communications Commission and current visiting professor to the Link Centre at Wits University, London School of Economics and Technical University of Denmark, argued strongly against Matsepe-Casaburri`s decision.

"Although the Independent Communications Authority of SA [ICASA] initially went through a credible and transparent SNO process, the minister`s decision to find an international investor in private is contrary to the spirit of transparency which was originally intended," says Melody.

"In addition to having a process that lacks transparency, the minister is trying to sell Telkom shares while attempting to identify a suitable competitor for the incumbent operator, an obvious conflict of interest."

He says it is frustrating that the country appears to have taken all the correct procedural steps on the surface, but there is no substance to this appearance.

Speaking of Telkom`s latest price hikes, Melody observed that, while the organisation claimed its latest price hikes were based on September`s increase in the price of maize and other foodstuffs, much of its costs were actually based on US and European currencies, against which the rand has appreciated by about 25%.

"Other costs include the purchase of telecommunications equipment, which has dropped internationally not only because of new technologies, but also because of collapsed markets, meaning that Telkom is increasing its profits based on an unrelated inflation in the cost of maize.

"The compensating factor for inflation is supposed to be productivity and Telkom proposed a productivity factor of 1.5% in its rate increases calculation, which was not acceptable to ICASA, which recommended 3% instead, thus reducing the allowed price increase."

He says the minister then reduced the Telkom productivity factor back to 1.5%, approving the full increase that Telkom requested.

"I believe ICASA`s chairman, Mandla Langa, is an extremely credible man, but he is stuck in a process that possibly lacks the same level of integrity," says Melody.

"When one considers recent comments made by president Thabo Mbeki, that he expects economic growth to be driven out of the ICT sector, it makes this situation all the more disturbing.

"There is no way that the sector will grow if it`s all tied up in knots as a result of a faulty process and questionable management."

CUASA chairman, Mike van den Bergh, says that while transparency would be ideal in a situation like this, it is equally important that a strong competitor to Telkom is found as soon as possible.

"The danger of not having strong competition is highlighted by Telkom`s recent tariff increases. While they were within the accepted parameters, they were not market-related and had there been a competitor, they would never have gotten away with such a steep tariff hike."

Van den Bergh, who is also a director at Goldleaf, one of the bidders for the SNO licence, says it is the outcome of the process that is critical.

"It is imperative that we have a second operator - whoever they may be - as quickly as possible. We cannot wait another year, as it would start to become too difficult for the SNO to compete against a thoroughly entrenched incumbent."

Related articles:
Govt misses SNO deadline
SNO saga marches on
ICASA may take action against minister
Govt takes second stab at SNO

Share