The Internet Service Providers` Association of SA (ISPA) believes there are ways for the state to channel its collective energies towards creating real and sustainable competition to Telkom, despite the apparent failure of the second national operator (SNO) process.
Following last week`s announcement by the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA) that neither bidder was found to be a suitable competitor to Telkom, in terms of the criteria specified by government, ISPA has suggested other ways to stimulate competition.
"We support ICASA`s appreciation and vision for creative options that may exist within the established legal and regulatory framework, which can be easily and speedily implemented to ensure competitive outcomes in the market," says Ant Brooks, co-chairman of ISPA`s regulatory sub-committee.
"Further delays in the introduction of competition in any form cannot be justified and will seriously compromise the viability of a future competitive sector, which is why we believe the minister should look at implementing some obvious competition-enhancing mechanisms that are already available in the Telecommunications Act, and which only require her assent to become operative."
He says that specifically, ISPA calls on the minister to immediately publish in the Government Gazette notices specifying:
- A date from which VANS (value-added network services) operators may provide their own facilities;
- A date from which VANS operators can carry voice; and
- A date from which VANS and PTNs (private telecommunications networks) may resell, cede and sublet facilities and in that regard, the immediate and unrestricted introduction of resale services as contemplated in the 1995 White Paper on telecoms policy.
"These options are all hardwired into the Telecommunications Act, all that is required is for the minister to okay them and set a date. There is no need for a process of consultation or deliberation, as there has been in the SNO situation," says Brooks.
"Such a move would immediately increase competition for Telkom, as it would allow VANS operators to set up their own infrastructure, rather than relying on Telkom, and it would give them more flexibility in terms of bundling of services."
He believes this will assist in removing the false distinction between voice and data, and to some degree, will alleviate the situation created by the Telecommunications Amendment Act in 2001, which gave selective licences to various operators competing in the VANS arena.
"Since each one of the above steps will incrementally help to increase competition in the telecoms arena, it may even stimulate enough foreign interest in our market that the kind of equity partner we are looking for may bid for the SNO a little further down the line," he says.
"There has never been a better time for the minister to make such a move. The SNO process is stalled and this offers a clear pathway towards stimulating competition with minimal effort on her part - it`s a win-win situation.
"This would also ease pressure on both the minister and ICASA, while they continue to seek other ways to create sustainable competition and/or seek an appropriate equity partner for the SNO."
Related stories:
Telecoms industry feels 'let down` by ICASA
ICASA rejects both SNO 51% bidders
Policy issues to be raised at Internet Week

