More complaints that Computer Faire is selling a database of e-mail addresses to spammers have come to light. This time the apparent culprit is the Job Navigator site at www.jobs.co.za. "We would like to introduce you to JobNavigator," the e-mail reads after greeting the recipient by name. It goes on to encourage registration at the site, which hosts jobseekers` CVs.
Job Navigator responded to complaints by explaining that Computer Faire had provided the database of online registrations at the Faire Web site, which was created by one of its sister companies.
"Nowhere on the form I filled in did it ask if I want to receive e-mail from anyone," says a recipient who did not want to be identified. "At no stage was it mentioned when enrolling at the Faire that our e-mail addresses would be sold to spammers," agrees another recipient, who likewise did not want to be identified.
So is this a clear case of unsolicited commercial e-mail? The previous company accused of using Computer Faire information to spam, Media Africa, argued that it had acted as "sub-contractors" to TML Reed, and was therefore not guilty of spam.
"How do you define spam?" asks Job Navigator director Niall Murphy. "The purpose of an exhibition is to help companies communicate, and it is in essence a marketing event. People who register with an exhibition should expect to receive promotional materials."
But a complainant argues that promotional material via snail-mail is no problem, but e-mail is not welcome as the recipient is forced to pay some of the costs.
While the organisers assumed that those who register would be interested in promotional material, they were never actually asked for their consent. This will change, promises exhibition manager Celeste Abroms. "In future we will ask those supplying their address if they want to receive mail," she says. The questionnaire will also narrow down the field of interest to deliver targeted mail. She adds that the database has not been made available to any other parties.
But that does very little to placate the angry individuals who perceive the e-mail as spam.
What made Job Navigator run the risk of being labelled a spamming site? "We didn`t quite think through all the implications of what we were doing," says Murphy. "There is a measure of regret now because some people are so upset." He claims that very few negative responses were received, and that positive feedback far outweighed that. "We had only 1% negative feedback," he says. Abroms says the database contained around 27 000 addresses.
Murphy adds that they will be very hesitant to use mass mailing in future. "I am not in the business of generic mailing, and I have no interest in using that database again." But even so he does not anticipate that spamming will become extinct anytime soon. "This is the reality of life, like junk mail is in the world outside. The Internet is no different."
Editorial contacts

