The report by Next Generation Consultants, analysing the bids of the two consortiums, Two Consortium and CommuniTel, seeking to win the 51% equity stake in the second national operator (SNO) has highlighted a number of deficiencies in these bids.
The report, which was released yesterday, was drafted by independent analysts contracted by the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA).
The report has accused both bidders of ignoring draft licence provisions, saying that both bids are financially deficient. The two original bids, from Goldleaf Trading and Optis Telecommunications, were both rejected for similar reasons.
Two Consortium was criticised on the fact that its bid was highly reliant on MTN, with whom it has no written agreement, and also on the fact that its offer - which the report states is essentially a merger with the cellular operator - may have difficulties in terms of the Competitions Act.
Next Generation also spoke out on the fact that the effective control of the SNO, thanks to a pyramid shareholding structure, was disproportionate to the real equity investment put in by the controlling company, Industri Kapital.
It also said Two had failed to evidence the ability of a capable management team, as its presentations had been done by consultants and business partners, and that the consortium`s normal role appeared to be as a consultant, rather than as a long-term network operator.
Equity participation
According to the report: "They have provided a plan where their main strategic partners are not equity partners. This raises the question of network and operational vulnerability.
"Their time to market is dependent upon due diligence, negotiations with the SOEs [state-owned enterprises] and ICASA and then the investment approval of their ultimate controlling shareholder.
"The extent of their equity participation appears to waiver and their participation appears to be subject to various escape clauses," states the report.
While the report is scathing in many respects, it also acknowledges that Two`s business plan is innovative and recognises the opportunities prevalent in the SNO and the impact of convergence.
It also says Two has put together a plan that "will be quick to market, cost-effective and will generate substantial revenue".
Criticism directed at both Two and its opposite number, CommuniTel, was that the bidders` net foreign investment into SA was not only initially minimal, but also heavily negative in later years.
Profits vs lower prices
Both bidders were also condemned for directing profits to shareholders, rather than being used to significantly lower prices and promote competition within the market.
Further criticisms of CommuniTel`s bid were that much of its stated experience in running SNOs was unsubstantiated, and that the consortium`s management and shareholders are primarily consultants, rather than being long-term major telecommunications operators.
Further issues highlighted by the report include the fact that "their strategic partners have a minimal network in SA; they have not provided proof of funding; and that there is a potential BEE [black economic empowerment] conflict with Nexus [the 19% BEE component of the licence]".
However, on the positive side, Next Generation stated that - while not aggressive - the business plan was "sound, well researched and displays an understanding of the South African market, while their financial plan is sound and assimilates well with their business plan".
Also, "they have a sound grasp of the SOEs` abilities and appear to be sensitive to the integration opportunities and problems, and Namibia Telecom may offer a significant advantage by enabling the SNO to have direct access to the SAT3 submarine cable and infrastructure for international traffic".
Bidders respond
Response to the report from the two rival bidders was muted, as both were wary of prejudicing the issue, prior to making their own responses, which must be sent to ICASA by Tuesday next week.
Two`s Yolanda Cuba says: "We have noted what was said in the report and the fact that Next Generation tried to be objective, but we do feel that there were some misunderstandings in terms of what we said and what was construed by the consultants.
"We will, however, do our best to clarify these points in our response to ICASA."
CommuniTel director, Mike van den Bergh, had a similar attitude, saying: "We recognise the amount of work Next Generation has put into the report, but there are certain areas where we disagree with what they have said.
"We plan to set the record straight in our response to ICASA, and hope to demonstrate that we are a strong and financially viable bidder who can comfortably operate in a competitive telecoms environment."
Related stories:
SNO unlikely to cause price war, says DiData
SA SNO bidder signs deal with Ghana SNO
Two Consortium clarifies equity position
SNO equity increase 'not a marriage proposal`
MTN hedges its SNO bets
SNO stakeholders question bids

