About
Subscribe

SAPO refutes software 'settlement`

Staff Writer
By Staff Writer, ITWeb
Johannesburg, 10 Feb 2003

The South African Post Office (SAPO) denies paying the Business Software Alliance (BSA) R711 392.74 in civil damages as reported, but says the payment was for licence fees for the use of Associates` anti-virus software.

But the BSA and Network Associates insist the payment was a damages claim SAPO agreed to settle after admitting it had infringed the company`s copyright by continuously using programs without a licence.

Twiggs Xiphu, SAPO corporate services executive, confirms the parastatal did make such a payment, but said it was paid to Network Associates as licence fees for the use of its anti-virus software from February to November 2002.

Christopher Bray, Network Associate`s regional director for sub-Saharan Africa, dismisses Xiphu`s claims.

"If the money was for outstanding licence fees then they would have paid us, not the BSA. SAPO agreed to a settlement with the BSA because it failed to renew its licence with us."

The BSA said last week it instructed SAPO to remove all copies of Network Associates` McAfee anti-virus software from its computers and pay the organisation R711 392.

Xiphu says SAPO "never used the software illegally or without prior knowledge or consent of the supplier, Network Associates.

"These payments were delayed at the time due to the Post Office having invited tenders to supply anti-virus software. Network Associates was made of the fact through correspondence at various levels and agreed to a monthly payment of licence fees."

Bray says matters between Network Associates and the parastatal came to a head in January last year after SAPO failed to pay it for licence fees. Network Associates lodged a complaint with the BSA, which in turn approached SAPO.

"SAPO fell out of licence in August 2001 and told us it could not renew it at the time because it was facilitating a tender. We gave them time until January 2002 to allow them to facilitate the tender."

Adheera Bodasing, a legal representative for the BSA, says the organisation concluded a settlement with SAPO on 4 June last year "whereby the parties agreed they were involved in a dispute regarding unlawful duplication and use of software programs published by Network Associates.

"SAPO acknowledged that copyright subsisted in the software programs of Network Associates and that its unauthorised continued use of Network Associates programs amounted to an infringement of Network Associates` copyright in their software programs."

She says it was also agreed that SAPO would erase and destroy all unlicensed copies of Network Associates software programs and that legal counsel for BSA would be allowed to confirm it.

"By way of compensation for its unlicensed reproduction and use of the Network Associates software programs, the Post Office paid an amount of R711 392 in damages."

Share