While Two Consortium - one of the bidders for the second network operator (SNO) licence - appears happy with the way the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA) has conducted the bid process, it is still furious at the way it was portrayed in Next Generation`s report.
Next Generation recently analysed both consortiums` bid documents, providing ICASA with an independent view, but has since been sharply criticised by the bidders for "oversights and misconceptions".
Two Consortium met with journalists last week to explain its problems with the Next Generation report and answer other questions.
"We feel that ICASA was very clear on its expectations and open with its process, doing a good job under challenging circumstances, but Next Generation made some sweeping assumptions and statements that could be regarded as derogatory," says Dr Kwame Amuah, Two`s chairman.
"For example, they effectively characterised Swedtel and Telenor as fly-by-night operators, which does the organisations a grave disservice, considering they operate in one of the strongest telecoms environments in Europe. They have completely ignored the pedigree that these operators have."
He also complains that Next refers several times to the process used to adjudicate the first round of bidding, even though there was a completely different process for the second round.
"Another issue that Next raised that we are angry with is its speculation that our management fees could be in the region of R1 billion over a six-year period - we consider a statement like that to be absolutely inflammatory and without substance," says Mac Allman, a senior advisor from Telenor.
Asked why Two`s shareholding was so broad-based, Allman says this came about because both Swedtel and Blue Planet were looking at the SNO independently, and decided they would be better off pooling their resources into a single bid - hence the current name, Two Consortium.
"Some people believe that the combination of these two partners has diluted the bid, but as far as we are concerned it has only strengthened it, as both partners bring different offerings to the table."
Responding to a question asking why Two is prepared to come in as a strategic equity partner (SEP) this time when its partners are generally better known as management partners, Amuah says that it is about risk.
"We don`t want to be viewed in the manner that management partners usually are - that is, the kind of company that comes in, earns massive fees and then pulls out when times get tough. We are prepared to put in the equity and accept our share of the risk," he says.
Amuah also commented on the issues raised in the media by Nexus Connexion, the 19% black economic empowerment (BEE) segment of the SNO, which has said that it agrees with the Next Generation report and is worried that Blue Planet (which also has black shareholding) may interfere with its BEE mandate.
"If I were in Nexus`s shoes, I think I would express similar sentiments, as it is a natural reaction - they are protecting their assets and shares, and want to be assured of the best SEP possible.
"By the same token, we have gone to great lengths to explain to them that we are not coming in to compete with them in terms of the BEE component. They are nervous that we will interfere with their ability to raise funds, but we plan to work together in an amicable manner, not to compete."
Asked whether Two would consider bidding again, should ICASA choose not to recommend either bidder (as occurred in the first process) and the SNO had to go to a third round of bidding, Allman says Two could only answer "maybe".
"It really would depend on a number of factors, such as what we thought of the opportunity at the time, what the structure and set-up of the bid process was and so on. After all, Telkom is getting stronger by the day, so we`d have to decide if it was worth it."
While Two would not rule out the possibility of a legal challenge if it was not awarded the SNO licence, Allman says it would be difficult to argue against the process followed by ICASA, as it has been fair and open throughout.
Related stories:
SNO bidders hammer Next Generation report
SOEs don`t want to run the SNO
Nexus, SOEs prepared to go it alone
Two Consortium slates bid report
Report highlights SNO bid deficiencies

