The two bidders for the second national operator (SNO) licence, CommuniTel and Two Consortium, have rounded on Next Generation (NG), sharply criticising that organisation`s analysis of their respective bid documents.
The bidding consortiums` responses to the NG analysis accuse the organisation of exceeding its mandate by comparing the two bids, making recommendations regarding a possible outcome and proposing alternative processes, when it was meant to do no more than analyse the bids` compliance with certain criteria.
In its response to the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA), CommuniTel says that the NG report compares the current applicants with one another, with applicants from the previous process, with the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and with the black economic empowerment (BEE) licence holder, Nexus Connexion.
Two Consortium charges NG with using selective quotations from the public hearings and making sweeping assumptions and conclusions about the financial investments required for the business, while ignoring the company`s fundamentally sound and innovative strategies.
One of the key issues raised by the consortiums is that of NG`s apparent naivety in terms of project finance, coupled to what they call the assumptive and highly speculative financial scenarios NG uses in determining that the bidders may not be contributing enough equity.
Two says the analysis makes sweeping assumptions around the value of the existing investments by the SOEs, setting out two "hypothetical values" for the SOE assets, namely being R1.5 billion and R3 billion.
"The statement is then made that the value must be viewed as equity, leading to the incorrect conclusion being drawn that the proposed equity contributions of both bidders is insufficient," states the Two response.
"NG`s approach to the funding requirements of the SNO clearly illustrates that the consultants have a limited understanding of the financial norms applicable to projects of this nature," says Deacon Mathe, CommuniTel`s chairman.
"One of the key criteria laid down by the minister was that the applicants needed to demonstrate an 'ability` to raise the necessary funding. CommuniTel has indisputably demonstrated such an ability - indeed, well above the amounts that will be required by the SNO."
Both bidders also criticise the fact that certain of their shareholders - Blue Planet and Invictus (Two Consortium) and CommuniTel`s Umkhonto We Sizwe Military Veterans` Association (MKMVA) - are held up as being further additions to the BEE element of the SNO, and therefore rivals to Nexus.
Two states emphatically that "neither shareholder is participating as a BEE company", and poses the question: "Can companies that have black shareholders only participate where they are BEE partners?"
CommuniTel says that while MKMVA is unashamedly a BEE player, it has entered into the bid process as an investor, holding a 25% shareholding in the consortium, and not from a BEE perspective, despite occupying an almost-unique position as a broad-based black empowerment grouping.
Ultimately, the bidders believe the conclusions reached in the NG analysis are at best misleading, as they rely on assumptions which the compilers of the analysis should not have made.
Their major concern appears to be that the report is inconsistent in its approach, and as such, feel strongly that the report cannot be taken at face value, but must be viewed critically in the light of the actual terms of reference handed down to NG by ICASA.
"NG has unfortunately, as a result of focusing its attention on areas which are irrelevant in terms of the laid down process, risked causing unnecessary delays to a successful conclusion of the process," says Mathe.
ICASA is due to study the responses and will then evaluate the two bids. This will be done by awarding points for specified criteria and the bidder with the highest points tally should - in theory at least - then be recommended for the licence, after which only ministerial approval will be needed.
ICASA says it hopes to make a recommendation of some kind to communications minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri by sometime next week.
Related stories:
SNO report criticism expected today
Two Consortium slates bid report
Report highlights SNO bid deficiencies

