About
Subscribe

SNO report criticism expected today

Rodney Weidemann
By Rodney Weidemann, ITWeb Contributor
Johannesburg, 19 Aug 2003

The two parties seeking to be awarded the second national operator (SNO) licence - Two Consortium and CommuniTel - will today have the opportunity to respond officially to last week`s Next Generation report, which strongly criticised both bids.

Next Generation is an independent analyst firm contracted by the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA) to study the two consortiums` bids. The consortiums` responses to the report are to be delivered to ICASA at 4.30pm today.

Following the release of the report, both CommuniTel and Two Consortium stated they would respond to ICASA to clear up the misunderstandings and miscommunications, and would use this opportunity to set the record straight.

Two Consortium later slated the report, saying that - while it is tabled in a framework of legitimacy - it is characterised by bias.

Although both bidders will not comment on the issue until they have delivered their responses to ICASA, an industry insider who is close to the process has suggested there will be a lot more than purely a clearing up of misunderstandings.

According to the insider, the bidders are critical of Next Generation`s ability to undertake such a study and are going to question the company`s experience in terms of its understanding of financial and business matters.

They also want the process whereby Next Generation was selected to be reviewed.

Much of the process that has been used in order to judge the financial and business plans is also being called into question, with the bidders apparently complaining that Next Generation has used the process designed for evaluating the original bids, which does not take cognisance of the fact that the bid conditions have changed.

Criticisms originally levelled at the bidders in the Next Generation report included the fact that their net foreign investment into the country was not only initially minimal, but also heavily negative in later years.

It also accused both bidders of ignoring draft licence provisions, saying both CommuniTel and Two Consortium`s bids were financially deficient. They were also condemned for directing profits to shareholders, rather than being used to significantly lower prices and promote competition within the market.

Finally, the report stated that the consortiums` management and shareholders are primarily consultants, rather than being long-term major telecommunications operators.

Although Next Generation acknowledged that the business plans were innovative and were either "quick to market, cost-effective and will generate substantial revenue" or were "sound, well researched and display an understanding of the SA market", this did little to please the bidders.

Related stories:
Two Consortium slates bid report
Report highlights SNO bid deficiencies

Share