About
Subscribe

SNO`s window of opportunity is shrinking

Rodney Weidemann
By Rodney Weidemann, ITWeb Contributor
Johannesburg, 28 Oct 2003

There is a specific window for the second national operator (SNO) to enter the telecoms market, and this opportunity is shrinking every single day the licence is delayed, so it is imperative that the minister makes a decision on awarding it as soon as possible.

This is the view of telecoms analyst Andre Wills, of Africa Analysis, who says the potential market share for the SNO is shrinking, because - while there may have been companies that held off on instituting new systems while awaiting the SNO - more and more of them are being forced into going with Telkom.

"The big issue here is that once these organisations have put so much time and money into new systems, they are not going to go through that again with an SNO, meaning that Telkom just continues to increase its market share," says Wills.

"The problem is that the SNO process has already taken far too long and we seem to be heading down the same road as the third cellular licence. After all, the hearings for the first round of SNO bidding took place in December last year, and we`re nearly a year down the line and have effectively not moved forward."

Weighing the options

He says there are numerous options the minister can exercise in order to get the ball rolling again, but that, as always, there are pros and cons to each of them.

"The first possibility is that the minister agrees with the ruling by the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA) that neither bidder is suitable, although it would truly surprise me if she did," he says.

"Not only would this take the process backwards, but it is pretty obvious to all and sundry that there were errors in the Next Generation report upon which ICASA based its findings."

He says another option would be to warehouse the 51% stake and award an interim licence to the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and Nexus Connexion, but that this would require a new process and would thus delay the SNO further anyway.

"Warehousing could prove to be a dangerous course, as I think the best value the government is going to get for the 51% stake is where it`s at now. If the shares are warehoused and the SNO does badly, then the likelihood of a major bidder coming in would inevitably decrease.

"On the other hand, she could choose to go for a third round of bidding, but this will create a bad impression internationally, because we`ll already have had two rounds of bidding without a result," says Wills.

"I think a better option would be to auction the licence to pre-qualified consortiums - at least this would be a transparent process and would hopefully generate good money."

Legal challenge?

Wills believes there is also a possibility that the minister will choose one of the bidders anyway, despite ICASA`s recommendation.

"This would be a slap in the face for ICASA and might send some bad signals to market in terms of ignoring the regulator, but at least it would get the process moving again.

"The only potential problem with this option is a possible legal challenge by the loser. We could then find ourselves with a similar scenario to the third cellular licence, when Nextcom challenged the awarding of the licence to Cell C," he says.

Wills says the final option open to the minister is the possibility of trying to get the two bidders to join forces - this would be similar to the concept of the so-called "super bid", which was one of the options considered by the SNO Working Committee at the beginning of the second process.

"I believe that something like this could prove to be a good solution, although it could conceivably take a lot of time, since the parties would have to agree on the terms of a merger, but on the flipside, the SNO would get the best of both bids while avoiding the pitfalls of legal challenges.

"Basically what it comes down to is that she has a number of options, each with an upside and a downside and whatever option is chosen, it will set the tone for the telecoms market for years to come. Thus it is a decision that needs to be carefully considered."

Department of Communications spokesman, Jerry Majatladi, says that at this point, the minister is still considering her options and there is no clear indication when she will make a decision.

Related stories:
SNO follows third cell licence`s rocky path
Transtel, Telkom face off at iWeek
No SNO clarity, no telecoms law overhaul

Share