Electronic networks are already firmly embedded and growing in importance as commerce platforms, with the Internet, in particular, boosting the volume and future importance of e-commerce, the industry`s most authoritative survey found.
The landmark 1999 South African Electronic Commerce Survey, conducted by IT and telecommunications market researchers and consultants BMI-TechKnowledge, shows that, according to senior information service managers` expectations, conducting business via electronic networks is set to grow in leaps and bounds over the next three years.
"It is also abundantly clear that the Internet is already widely accepted as a mainstream commerce platform, and is perceived by most respondents to be the most significant catalyst for the rapid growth of electronic commerce," BMI-T director Brian Neilson writes in the survey report published this week.
There is currently a debate in the industry as to whether consumer e-commerce is taking off. The survey finds that it is, provided a liberal definition of on-line shopping is adopted - which includes shopping around for items prior to purchasing through traditional methods. This is to be expected for products such as cars and property, but the survey found that it also applies to other categories such as computer hardware and software.
The survey was conducted among a representative sample of more than 1000 businesses and 1800 households in South Africa and complemented by BMI-T`s vast local and international (through International Data Corporation [IDC]) knowledge base. "It provides us with comprehensive data that can be cut and sliced to give an accurate overview of e-commerce by industry sector, business application or demographic group," says Neilson.
The survey report findings are organised in two sections, the business and household surveys. The business section is further split into general e-commerce and Internet commerce, while the household survey looks at individuals and households separately.
The Business Survey: General e-commerce
Electronic commerce is already firmly embedded and expected to grow significantly over the next three years. According to the survey, 26% of large companies, 20% of medium companies and 16% of small companies claim to be conducting at least some commerce over one or more electronic network currently. This proportion is expected to grow to 38%, 31% and 28%, respectively, by 2002.
Perhaps more significantly, "organisations across all industry sectors revealed a surprisingly high proportion of total sales taking place across electronic networks, and a nearly universal expectation of growth in this regard in the next three years," Neilson writes.
Call centres are being used as a sales channel by between 10% and 14% of small and large companies, respectively. However, Neilson qualifies: "This is a fairly broad definition of a call centre, and includes unsophisticated processes and small operations. This varies widely by industry sector, and from company to company within a particular sector."
Of all network types, the public Internet and World Wide Web, with the usual security precautions, is perceived by most respondents in all organisation size categories to be the most important. Up to 20% expect to adopt Quality of Service (QoS) networks tunnelled via the public Internet over the next three years.
The vast majority of those companies employing e-commerce as a sales channel offer conventional payment methods, with fewer than 40% offering credit card payment, and less than 20% other forms of payment. (This result applies to all e-commerce methods, not just Internet e-commerce).
Courier delivery is most widely used by smaller companies employing e-commerce as a sales channel. Large companies use couriers to the same extent as smaller companies, but make even higher usage of their own road freight and distribution to local agents/outlets and warehouses.
Between 17% and 19% of large, medium and small organisations purchase products and services electronically currently. A relatively even spread exists between those purchasing capital goods, goods for resale, and other items.
Small and medium-sized companies expect very high growth in electronic procurement systems that will be integrated with ERP systems - coming off a very small base currently. Large companies have the highest expectations for ultimate implementation, with more than two thirds expecting integrated procurement systems by 2002. A large proportion of these is expected to be Web enabled.
The Business Survey: Internet commerce
Internet commerce has already established a firm foothold in SA businesses. This position is expected to strengthen significantly over the next three years.
"The majority of large organisations believe that the Internet will be an important e-commerce platform a year from now - if not already - with both customers and suppliers," Neilson says. "The World Wide Web is already perceived to be a suitable business channel, both in support of existing selling channels and as an alternative channel."
According to the survey findings, the vast majority of large, medium and small companies in South Africa already have at least some access to the Internet (97%, 89% and 80%, respectively). The proportion of all PCs that are Internet connected has also grown substantially, with an average of close to 40% across large, medium and small companies. This proportion is expected to grow by a further 8% in the next 12 months.
The incidence of Web sites varies widely across large (61%), medium (39%) and small (28%) companies. Just over half of those without a Web site are planning to have one in the next year or two.
According to Neilson, the majority of Web sites are currently best described as "static marketing information" sites. Less than 10% are integrated with legacy systems, and fewer than 20% are integrated with supply chain or logistics management systems, or allow customers to place an order directly from the Web site. "However, the majority plan to commerce-enable their Web sites in the next one-to-three years."
In cases where Web sites are already commerce enabled, the majority of sales leads are followed up using traditional methods (more than 73% of large, medium and small companies), or using e-mail (between 38% and 49% use this method). The majority of large companies expect to cater for payment authorisation via the Internet in a year or two from now. Security fears remain a key inhibitor or obstacle to introducing e-commerce functionality to the Web site. Complexity of implementation and, in the case of smaller companies, high cost of deployment, are equally important inhibitors. Firewalls and passwords are the most frequently used security measures currently, even in large organisations. Only a third use data encryption and less than 20% use digital certificates. Sectors such as banking and government are understandably exceptions, with a higher usage of all security measures.
The majority of large, medium and small companies all believe that the responsibility for providing a secure platform for e-commerce lies with the Internet Service Provider. However, shared responsibility was also perceived to be the norm, with the buyer, seller and the bank all playing a role.
"Only 6% of large, 3% of medium, and 2% of small companies could estimate the proportion of total revenue derived from their Web sites currently. Of those who could, the amount reported was surprisingly high - between 12% and 22% on average for small and large companies, respectively."
The majority of large, medium and small companies reported spending less than R40 000 on their Web sites initial implementation. At the other extreme, 3% of the large companies claimed to have spent over R1 million. Ongoing maintenance costs each year tend to be in the same range as the initial implementation cost - and this result seems to apply relatively similarly across the wide range of spending categories.
The majority of large, medium and small companies develop and maintain their Web sites internally. "There is still a role for external service providers in about a third of the cases."
The majority of large organisations now claim to have an Intranet. A surprisingly high proportion of smaller organisations also claims to have one. Intranet adoption will continue to grow at a high rate in the next 12 months. The rate of adoption of extranets is about half that of Intranets. Accordingly, an even higher growth rate is expected.
The Household Survey: Individuals
Two primary factors influence Internet commerce activity among individuals, the survey found: income and Internet literacy.
According to the survey, there has been widespread adoption of the Internet among individuals in the higher income brackets in the past 18 months. 20% of individuals in LSM 8, the highest income bracket, are active Internet users. A higher proportion of individuals in higher income brackets has home access and higher income bracket users are also twice as likely to adopt Internet shopping or banking. Most current active Internet users use the Internet at least once a day.
Most tertiary students already use the Internet. However, the majority of these individuals prefer to access the Internet at home than at the educational establishment. Employees, students and those with their own business spend an average of almost 200 minutes a week on the Internet. Housewives, retired persons, and unemployed persons spend an average of 130 minutes a week.
There is a very high correlation between PC ownership and Internet literacy. Advanced Internet users are much more likely to be conducting Internet banking, Internet shopping and making reservations on-line. 22% of advanced users shop on-line, compared with 14% of those with average Internet literacy and 8% of those with limited literacy.
E-mail is the highest adopted Internet application (95% of Internet users), followed by research, receiving general news, downloading business software, chat/conferencing. Internet banking has already been adopted by 36% of advanced Internet users, 22% of those with average literacy, and 20% of those with limited literacy.
Making reservations (including travel, accommodation or entertainment/event ticketing) has already been adopted by 27% of advanced Internet users, 22% of those with average literacy, and 12% of those with limited literacy. "This is slightly higher than the percentage of Internet shoppers. However, interestingly, the overlap between these two categories of users is far more limited than the results suggest - only a third of those who make reservations online also do Internet shopping or banking," Neilson says.
Two thirds of Web shoppers make use of search engines as a first attempt to find what they are looking for. Personal referral by friends, and printed media advertising, also have a key role to play, with 50% of the respondents being influenced in each of these sources. A high proportion of Internet users plan to adopt Web shopping in the next six months, in most product and services categories. This represents very high growth expectancy, coming off a very low base currently, especially when analysed by specific product category.
Many Web shoppers are using the Web to only search for products and services they need, thereafter completing the transaction through traditional methods. This is not only the case for cars and property, but also for items such as computer hardware and software.
Security of sensitive information is still a prime concern for prospective Web shoppers. 44% of respondents mentioned privacy of their personal information as being the major inhibitor to conducting frequent shopping online. 75% agreed with the statement that providing credit card information via the Web is the single most important reason that they don`t buy on the Web more often.
Most current Web shoppers have had a generally positive experience with their activities to date. 24% reported having a generally dissatisfying experience "once or twice", and none reported this to be a frequent occurrence.
Only 29% of shoppers provide their full credit card numbers online currently, while this should grow to 36% including those who appear willing to do so in future. A similar number (37%) would be happy to use a smart card as an online payment method.
The postal service is currently the delivery method used by most consumers who are buying online. Users will make use courier services and delivery of the goods to a local agent or outlet, if they are to buy on-line more often. This will justify the costs of using expensive courier services.
The Household Survey: Households
Nearly 1 million South African households, representing 10.5% of all households in the country, will have some form of Internet access by 2003. Two thirds of these are in LSM8.
The number of active Internet users in households grows from just over 500 000 in 1998 to 1.84 million by 2003, representing 4.4% of the entire population of 42 million people. Of these, 1.3 million are in LSM 8.
The high incidence of decoders and satellite TV indicates a potential for broadband Internet access (for the downlink), and the suitability of TV set-top boxes as the next growth area for alternative access devices - at least in this high income segment of the population. However, BMI-T still believes that Smart Handheld Devices (including smart phones) will lead NetTVs in this country.
BMI-TechKnowledge
BMI-TechKnowledge Group (BMI-T) is Africa`s leading supplier of quality, research based IT and telecommunications information services and consulting. Based in Johannesburg and Nairobi, Kenya (BMI-T Africa), the company has an experienced team of IT and telecoms specialists, as well as a network of researchers across the African continent.
Founded in 1979, BMI-T has actively researched the IT and telecoms industries since 1984. BMI-TechKnowledge was formed as a separate company in 1990 and from 1992 has represented International Data Corporation (IDC) in South Africa. BMI-T is part of the Qorus Group.
BMI-T`s World Wide Web site (www.bmi-t.co.za) contains additional company information and recent press releases, as well as a full list of research reports with abstracts and tables of contents.
International Data Corporation (IDC)
Headquartered in Framingham, Mass. USA, IDC provides IT market research and consulting to more than 3 900 high technology customers around the world. With a global network of 375 analysts in more than 40 countries, IDC is the industry`s most comprehensive resource on worldwide IT markets, products, vendors and geographies.

