With technology providing opportunities for 'doing things differently', Internet start-ups are leading the way with both spectacular successes and failures. Although record plunges in stock prices across the globe show a broad disillusionment with tech stocks, this is not deterring entrepreneurs from starting new enterprises driven primarily by technology.
In the HR or 'people management' field, many such entrepreneurial examples can be seen, from the huge increase in online recruitment businesses, to HR-related service and information providers. With rapid and easy access to the new economy, entrepreneurs are able to offer services across national boundaries with service levels and content beyond traditional means.
Although in general, HR professionals have been slower in turning technology opportunities into business ideals, these opportunities have already transformed many traditional HR functions in a few short years.
However, the relatively slow pace of this change can be attributed to the general problem HR has as a profession: not readily adopting technology as a means of solving business problems. It is also related to the relatively small numbers of HR professionals actively using the Internet, or technology in general, as a value-adding business tool.
At a recent series of events with HR professionals in various African countries, involving both businesses and students currently undergoing their Masters program in HR, I tried to ascertain the types of information and services used. It seems there are a number of us in Africa 'testing the waters', through accessing a variety of HR-related sites online in order to research and stay abreast of current affairs and trends.
I found, however, that there were no common sites visited nor any recognised HR portal or entry point for the HR professional in Africa. With almost no exceptions, all information accessed was from US content providers and reflected success stories and articles relating to US companies.
Although many of these may involve global operations of US-based companies, Africa is poorly serviced by local organisations offering either African examples in the fields of employee development or local successes and experiences.
A business opportunity therefore exists to consolidate HR content and services across the continent in order to focus global 'viewers' on the possibilities we can offer, for example in the areas of diversity management and labour optimisation. A current risk, for Africa, is that entrepreneurs wanting to start such operations often look abroad for hosting services.
Internet access costs
According to well-known South African IT journalist, Marina Bidoli 'Cheaper to Go Abroad' (01), high charges by local service providers for broadband infrastructure have played a large part in forcing African businesses, looking to capitalise on the successes of international Internet players, to turn to locating themselves overseas.
In addition, while the internal connectivity speed achieved within companies is reasonably fast, external connections are almost unusable to all but the really patient!
Bidoli concludes that this infrastructure requirement, almost entirely state controlled and owned across the continent, will not support the heavy hitting requirements of a world driven by the needs of online intellectual capital. It will be countries that manage this real need and turn requirements into business opportunity - such as initiatives in India, Mauritius and Malaysia - which will "turn the recipe into tasty profits while we fiddle".
Zimbabwe - Bob's watching
Another disturbing announcement diminishing the potential of local service providers and pushing people to use services outside their internal markets has surfaced in Zimbabwe recently. Bidoli (02) reports that Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe recently passed a special Bill forcing e-mail and Internet Service Providers to allow government, in the interests of national security, to view all communications into and out of the country.
In essence any disparaging comments about government, political, social or economic issues could lead to services being discontinued and fine of between $5 000 and $25 000 and a two year prison term. Although some Zimbabweans have taken the step of mailing friends, colleagues and family to discourage them from forwarding 'sensitive' information, even more will take the route of placing their e-mail and hosting services 'offshore'.
Paul Harper of Business Systems Group - Africa (02) as part of Bidoli's article, adds some comment to this area, by explaining software needed for 'watchdog' purposes starts at around $150 per user. He believes it is highly unlikely governments such as Zimbabwe could afford the $900 000 - $2 250 000 required for a project of this nature.
Anthony Brooks, a Zimbabwean Internet consultant, states: "It is practically impossible to search all e-mail coming in and out of the country. One can compare it to trying to search all the mail passing through a post office." Although the possibility of warehouses of government 'Internet police' scanning every mail and monitoring services offered seems improbable, it would certainly be possible on a selected basis as it is with traditional postal services and phone tapping.
Communications revolution
Positive moves within Africa include the privatisation trend in Nigeria, where prior to May 29 1999 on the new government taking office, telecommunications was described by Taylor (03) as "chaotic". Africa's most populous country, with a population exceeding 100 million, had only 700 000 telephone lines and a mere 500 000 connected. One of the first new government initiatives was the formation of a committee to chart a new telecomms policy.
This has already led to a number of new players and a partial freeing of what was a state controlled enterprise and so too, providing the opportunity to offer services at internationally competitive prices.
Taylor states the international trend of completely opening up markets works within developed markets, but requires more careful management and control within the developing world. This is due to the need to ensure new infrastructure players do not merely play the role of 'cream-skimming', that is addressing urban and international call requirements while the need for a broader infrastructure, providing communication services to the general population, is ignored. If this is seen as the only market left to the state run enterprises, this trend would in all likelihood result in fewer having access to information, negating advances made in connecting people over the last five years.
The privatisation process, while ensuring service levels are not affected for certain customers through cross subsidisation, makes for a complicated regulatory environment. Says Taylor: "The communications market is no longer national; globalisation is accelerating, raising technical, commercial and legal issues, which increasingly require global solutions."
Creswell agrees, (05) talking about the change in the global telecom landscape. "Massive change is underway, and the process is neither simple nor smooth. Country after country has loosened regulations. The Internet has exploded. New fibre-optic networks have made the incumbents' service seem as archaic as smoke signals sent via a camp fire and blanket." The question is can we keep up?"
Internet in Africa
In an article by O'Kane, (04), he quotes The World Bank president, James Wolfensohn, as saying: "My experience in poor communities is that they don't want a handout of money, they want a chance to learn and to be able to develop themselves, and there is no more efficient mechanism to convey knowledge back than the use of the Internet."
For this reason, The World Bank has announced a $500 million project in association with Japanese Internet group, Softbank.
Some are not so confident of the capabilities of technology to transform. Speaking at the African Development Forum, Mali's president, Alpha Oumar Konare stated: "As an African, I'm keeping a cool head - a computer can cost eight years salary or send 20 children to school. If we don't have our own clear vision on information and communication technology, we will be disappointed."
Add this to the figures provided by the UN Economic Commission for Africa (ECA) in previous articles carried by the IHRIM Journal. These show there are only 0.5 main lines per 100 people in sub-Saharan Africa (excluding South Africa). It is estimated that 4.5 million new lines would be needed at a cost of $6-8 billion.
Despite all these obstacles, it is happening. Many do see, and understand, the long-term benefits of driving Africa along a technology revival as well as the benefits that could be gained from ensuring our international competitiveness.
Since the enormity of providing facilities to all seems so daunting, it is to the youth we look. With projects such as the Schoolnet Africa initiative, working to connect schools across Africa to the Internet, we are likely to see the growth in job seekers with at least a basic computer background and a willingness to learn.
These projects are often not led by business initiatives but focus, as does Schoolnet Africa, on HIV/AIDS awareness, peace building and cultural preservation type projects. For business purposes these seem like noble causes, but would probably show greater returns in the short to medium term if they were re-focused on adding value to their home markets by teaching elements of a new economy to fresh minds.
The universities or tertiary institutions have also been slow to react, with few offering a changed curriculum to traditional business courses. It is in this area that HR has the most to offer. By re-looking at the corporate education spend, and redirecting both internal and external development initiatives into thinking about possibilities brought about by the 'new economy', we may be able to support a radical change in the skills base and services to offer a global audience.
We have started this change, with the innocent introduction of Employee Self Service (ESS). ESS is seen elsewhere in the world as a way of drastically reducing administrative costs and increasing the productivity of the HR function. Although it can't necessarily be sold as a cost saver when costs of labour are so low ranging from as little as $5-00 per month, we view it as a means of introducing possibilities to staff.
You begin with self-service around basic administrative tasks, over time increasing this to include self-development and eventually self-management. This is a slow process of transformation, transforming employees into knowledge workers capable of making use of technological advances, but more importantly capable of identifying new opportunities for organisations to participate in global economies.
According to Djibril Diallo, the director of public affairs at the UN Development Programme (UNDP), if Africa is to reduce its poverty by half, it will need a growth rate of around 7%. For the first time in many years, this is a real possibility as Africa begins to increase growth from around 3.3 % in 1998 compared with 2.9 % in 1997.
Only through a quantum leap will it further increase on this trend and make the drastic change to growth levels that will drive the often mooted African Renaissance. As HR professionals, our task is to take the learning from the emerging economy and turn these into real business opportunities within the African context.
References:
- Marina Bidoli, "Internet Access - Cheaper to go Abroad," Financial Mail, March 24 2000, pp. 33.
- Marina Bidoli, "Bob's Watching You - Dotty com to monitor e-mail", Financial Mail, March 24 2000, pp. 36.
- Shola Taylor, "Communications Revolution", Business in Africa, March 2000, pp. 20-21.
- Gerry O'Kane, "World Bank to boost Internet in Africa", African Business, March. No 252 2000, pp. 30.
- Julie Creswell, "Telecom's Mixed Signals", Fortune, April. No 7, pp. 51-56.

