About
Subscribe

Telecoms industry feels 'let down' by ICASA

Rodney Weidemann
By Rodney Weidemann, ITWeb Contributor
Johannesburg, 29 Aug 2003

The only organisation in SA that will be happy with the Independent Communications Authority of SA's (ICASA) decision not to recommend either of the two bidders for the second national operator (SNO) licence will be Telkom.

This appears to be the view of the bidding consortiums (CommuniTel and Two Consortium), independent analysts and the majority of the general public. They are also concerned about the length of time the process is taking. Initially, an SNO was expected by mid-2002.

The industry reaction follows ICASA's recommendation yesterday that government formally close the 51% application process under the present circumstances, believing instead that government can channel its collective energies towards creating real and competition to the incumbent.

Time is of essence

"At this point, the winner is Telkom and the loser is the rest of SA, although we must still await the minister's final decision," says Mike van den Bergh, a director of CommuniTel.

"ICASA has failed SA and given Telkom even more time to further entrench itself and to get a head start in gaining control of new markets," says Two Consortium's Yolande Cuba.

"The one thing that SA could not afford was for this second process to be inconclusive - it is imperative for the industry and the consumer that the SNO licence be awarded as soon as possible, as the country cannot wait much longer for the SNO," says Andre Wills, an independent telecoms analyst.

"We were supposed to have a licensed SNO by May last year, so this process has been dragging on far too long and needs to be resolved."

Andrew Weldrick, Telkom's senior manager for media relations, says the company has always advocated the need for strong competition.

"We believe that a strong competitor will be good for us, for the industry as a whole and for the consumer, who will finally have a tangible operator to compare our value proposition against. We have already demonstrated that we are ready for competition," says Weldrick.

"We respect the process that ICASA has used, however, and will be interested to see what the minister will decide and what the next step in the SNO process will be."

Van den Bergh says CommuniTel finds ICASA's decision to be somewhat baffling.

"We had already pre-qualified thanks to our expression of interest and our discussions with the SNO working committee, so for ICASA to say we were deficient after the working committee found us good enough to recommend is strange, to say the least.

"We simply hope that the minister will apply her mind to the broader picture and ask what is best for the country before she makes her final decision. You have to remember that the minister originally did not even want ICASA involved in the second process."

Legal ramifications?

Discussing the possibility of legal action, Peter Archer, CommuniTel's CEO, says: "We do believe there is a basis for a legal challenge, but it is far too early to be talking about legal action. Let's first wait and see what decision the minister comes to."

Two Consortium's chairman, Dr Kwame Amuah, says the Next Generation report, which ICASA used in helping it come to its decision, clearly positioned both of the equity applicants as unqualified and outlined an alternative scenario of the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and Nexus Connexion - which own the remaining 49% - going it alone.

"A recommendation of this nature was clearly outside the mandate granted to the consultants, and the fact that they overstepped the boundaries of their mandate is a very serious matter," says Amuah.

It seems possible that this overstepping of the mandate could also be used in a legal challenge, should one be mounted by either of the bidders.

Both Karl Socikwa, CEO of Transtel, one of the SOEs, and Kennedy Memani, chairman of Nexus, feel it is imperative that the SNO is licensed soon, whether there is an equity partner or whether the other shareholders must run it without one.

"We need to have the entity licensed as soon as possible, in order to begin laying the foundations for an SNO. Whatever the minister's decision, we believe she needs to be quick in exercising her prerogative," says Socikwa.

"I do not find ICASA's decision to be very surprising, and we will support whatever decision the minister makes, but I agree that we need to get the SNO licensed - one way or another - very soon," says Memani.

Time will tell

MTN, which has already expressed a willingness to work with whichever bidder was awarded the 51% stake, has said it will adopt a wait and see approach, and will only comment on the issue once the minister has made her final decision.

"SA's economy has been suffering from the ill-effects of a long-term communications monopoly. This sometimes on, sometimes off SNO process casts serious doubt over the country's commitment to change and innovation in the industry," says Ray Webber of the Communications Users Association of SA.

"A number of our members are highly suspicious of government's motives with regard to the SNO process. Some suspect a far-reaching plot by government to run both fixed operators as mainly state-owned companies - flying in the face of real competition and their so-called commitment to the World Trade Organisation."

Related stories:
SNO bidder rejection is 'shock recommendation'
ICASA rejects both SNO 51% bidders
SNO bidders hammer Next Generation report

Share