South Africa should have had a second national operator (SNO) five years ago, which would have meant that by now, the country would have had a truly liberalised telecoms market.
This was the view expressed by Dr Angus Hay, Transtel`s chief technology officer, to participants at Internet Week (iWeek), which concludes today. He was discussing how the SNO plans to face up to the challenge of Telkom.
Transtel, along with Esi-Tel and Nexus Connexion, holds 49% of the SNO licence, while the remaining 51% has been allocated for a strategic equity partner, although at this point, one has not been found and the industry is awaiting the communications minister`s decision on this issue.
"At this point, everyone is suffering because of our lack of an SNO, whether it is the public, the customers or the bidders themselves. In fact, the only organisation to benefit from these endless delays is the incumbent," said Hay.
"The sad part is that Telkom`s monopoly was supposed to have ended in May last year, and even if the SNO is licensed soon, the company will have had almost a further two years of exclusivity, giving it time to entrench itself further."
Hay said that - looking at SNOs around the world - incumbents have a tendency to be predictable on certain issues, and there is little reason for our SNO to expect anything different.
"Incumbents generally hide behind regulations, use the practice of deny, delay and degrade to entrench their position, occasionally take the law into their own hands and always make a point of offering special pricing to the target markets they can least afford to lose.
"There are many good reasons why SA needs an SNO. It is essential that we have large-scale facilities competition, as you need muscle if you want to really make a dent in Telkom`s monopoly, so it is imperative to have a company that can challenge Telkom on an equal footing, particularly in terms of regulatory issues and anti-competitive behaviour."
He said the other key reason for an SNO is that it will provide access to another national backbone.
"This other network is real and does exist. We have been busy building it, it is just that we have no licence and as such are not allowed to use it - yet."
Yardstick needed
According to Nkenke Kekana, Telkom`s group executive for regulatory and public policy, the incumbent cannot wait for the SNO to be licensed.
"We have said on numerous occasions that we want competition as soon as possible. Only when there is a yardstick for comparison will people become aware of just how good our service actually is," said Kekana.
He said that as the leader in fixed-line communications in SA (which drew substantial laughter, since Telkom is the only fixed-line operator in SA) the company is well placed for competition, in terms of products, services and tariffs.
Speaking on the convergence issue, Hay said the SNO is not afraid of the proposed convergence legislation, as long as it is phased in slowly.
Kekana, however, is of the opinion that the SNO in particular will require some form of "protection" from the regulator, as once the legislation comes into play, there will be so many other competitors in the telecoms environment that it may pose a problem for the SNO.
"If there is anyone from the Department of Communications listening," said Hay, "please pass a message on to the minister that we would really like to see the SNO licensed sometime before the convergence bill is passed."
Related story:
Looking to the telecoms future

