About
Subscribe
  • Home
  • /
  • Internet
  • /
  • Video update: GIBS forum renews regulation debate

Video update: GIBS forum renews regulation debate

Phillip de Wet
By Phillip de Wet, ITWeb contributor
Johannesburg, 21 Sept 2000

At a new economy and legislation discussion at the Gordon Institute of Business Science (GIBS) last night, industry representatives were less than keen on what they see as restrictive government regulation.

[VIDEO]Michael Silber, a director of Aurica legal advisors, pointed out the difficulty of applying current laws to the environment and the need for sector specific legislation, but cautioned against extremes.

[VIDEO] "In the US you can do everything but [certain illegal activities], while in China and Vietnam you can only do the following [regulated activities]," he said, describing the available options. "I hope that SA is looking for something in the middle."

[VIDEO]Mike van den Bergh, director of value-added service (VANS) provider FirstNet, called for reactive regulation, saying it should establish a clear framework and then "step back" and give the industry freedom. "If something is not working, there is an obligation on government to step in, fix what is not working, and step back again."

[VIDEO]Van den Bergh is also the chairman of the SA VANS Association (SAVA), which has had running regulatory battles with Telkom for years.

[VIDEO]Telecommunications regulator the Independent Communications Authority of SA (ICASA) agrees there is a need for regulation, but also warned against restrictive regulation.

Flexibility needed

[VIDEO] "ICASA recognises that regulation during this [Internet] era will have to be innovative and flexible," said Mandla Msimang, an advisor representing the ICASA council. She warned that prescriptive rules would be outdated even before they could be implemented. "Our role in the new economy is to support the industry and to protect consumers."

[VIDEO]Whatever the course government chooses to take, the GIBS speakers agreed that a clear policy is needed as a matter of urgency, if only as a message to the international investment community.

[VIDEO] "Even if you have no regulation, a de facto environment is created while you are sitting in limbo, making new regulation increasingly difficult and ineffective," said Van den Bergh.

Government perspective

[VIDEO]The discussion was quite different from that held at the Highway Africa conference in Grahamstown last week, where Mojalefa Moseki of the Department of Communications made it clear that the Internet is a regulated medium, and should be further regulated.

[VIDEO] "The fact that the Internet is a new media and that SA has recognised that it will play a central economic role has allowed the Internet to grow without control over it," he said, making reference to recent high-profile cases of child pornography on the Internet. "Because of the bad things that are happening, everyone is standing up and saying it should be regulated, and the government cannot stand by and just watch these things happen. I believe 100% that the Internet should be regulated."

[VIDEO]Moseki does not see self-regulation by the industry as a viable option. "Most people prefer self-regulation, but everywhere else self-regulation has failed," he said. "Self-regulation has not only failed in SA, but it is not proper for a new market such as the Internet where there is so much money to be made and people can just come in and abuse all the rules that are there."

[VIDEO]He foresees a specific regulatory authority for the Internet, to be built around a domain name registrar for the dot co, dot za domain. "What we in government say is that the country top level domain name is in fact a national asset and should be recognised as such. It should belong to a structure that the government endorses." Such a structure, he said, could be extended to security certification and other areas.

Unequivocal 'no`

At the same forum, Brian Goulden, a PricewaterhouseCoopers telecoms consultant working in Botswana, took an opposite view.

[VIDEO] "If anyone asked me for an unequivocal answer, should the Internet be regulated, yes or no, I would say no, because I am afraid of the implications." His main concern is the subjective form content regulation is sure to take.

[VIDEO] "Regulation on the Internet will not stop [child pornography and fraud], but that doesn`t mean we shouldn`t try. But will that be used as an excuse by some unscrupulous governments to regulate further freedom of expression? The issue about content can be used as an opportunity to suppress a lot of things. Who draws the line of acceptability?"

[VIDEO]According to Moseki, the e-commerce green paper will lay the groundwork for regulation, and as it is only expected in early October, time is running out while the debate continues.

Video by Andrea Carroll

Share