Claims that Computer Faire is providing an e-mail database to a third-party for commercial use has renewed the debate around mass-mailing.
An e-mail from technology portal Gadget to previous Faire visitors had some recipients, who did not want to be named, reaching for their guns and demanding action against the senders. "As part of its service to previous Computer Faire visitors," reads the first paragraph of the e-mail, "TML-Reed Exhibitions has entered an arrangement with Media Africa to send you special editions of the Gadget weekly newsletter."
"By no definition can this be called spam," says Media Africa editor-in-chief Arthur Goldstuck.
"I wasn`t asked for permission before my personal information was provided to these people," says one recipient. "This is unacceptable; it is spam."
So when is spam really spam? The mail was sent out to those who had provided their addresses to the Faire and expressed interest in receiving further information. They did not, a few disgruntled recipients say, ask to receive marketing material from a portal.
But Computer Faire says that Media Africa was simply an intermediary that distributed information on behalf of TML-Reed Exhibitions. "This is supposed to be a value-add on behalf of the Faire," says exhibition manager Celeste Abroms. "There seems to have been a misunderstanding, or maybe it was not explained clearly enough."
Cathy Stadler of Media Africa sees Gadget as a sub-contractor. "TML requested the service from us. I would not call that spam."
Abroms seems to be correct in suspecting a misunderstanding on the part of recipients. "I received messages from Computer Faire," one says, "and I have no problem with that. But this is something else, and there is no justification."
Goldstuck says that a certain number of negative responses can be expected from any mass-mailing, even when a carefully qualified list is used. Spam is, after all, an emotional issue. But he says appreciation for the service has far outweighed such criticism. "We have had a steady stream of requests for more information. Only a couple of people regarded it as spam and reacted to it that way."
So how do you prevent your valuable service from being regarded as spam? Goldstuck has a few pointers for those who use mass-mailings; a strategy he says Media Africa has developed over time.
Make sure the list is qualified and not simply a random sample.
Keep the mail small. People do not appreciate their mailboxes being flooded.
Be specific and to the point. Keep the subject matter in line with what people would expect.
Make full disclosure of the source of the message, the reason it was sent and where the address was obtained. Add return e-mail paths, name the people involved and provide telephone numbers when possible.
Make it clear that immediate removal is possible and provide simple and efficient unsubscribe information.
Using these guidelines, he says, Media Africa has successfully used e-mail to conduct research and provide information with only a minimal backlash. But there is no way to please everyone. "Some people will always see this as spam."
So are these anti-spammers simply overreacting? No, says one of the recipients who demanded action from the Gadget ISP. "This is a small incident, but you have to stop this kind of thing fast. You never know what kind of information they may provide next. This is a privacy issue, a principal issue."
Editorial contacts

