The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has deemed as misleading Pastel Software`s claim that "9 out of every 10 accountants recommend Pastel" and has instructed Pastel to withdraw all advertising using this claim. The advertising campaign ran for over a year.
Dean Harrison, marketing manager for Softline Pastel, says the figure was based on two independent studies, which looked at over 200 accountants who recommend software to their clients.
ACCPAC challenged this claim, commissioning its own survey of all accountants.
"ACCPAC commissioned Pulse Research and Marketing to conduct a survey to establish the validity of the Pastel claim," says Jeremy Waterman, MD of ACCPAC Africa. "The survey not only disproved the '9 out of 10 claim`, it revealed that contrary to popular belief, the majority [over 60%] of accountants surveyed do not recommend any software at all."
ACCPAC then launched a short-term counter-campaign, stating that "6 out of 10 accountants do not recommend any brand of accounting software".
"Not surprisingly, this caused a stir in the market and we were asked to discontinue our ad campaign pending further investigation by the ASA," says Waterman.
"ACCPAC gave the results of its research to the ASA and the ruling came back a few weeks later in the form of an official statement: 'a misleading impression is created by the advert that the claim contained therein is correct in an unqualified manner`. Accordingly, the company in question has been instructed to withdraw the advertisement with immediate effect," says Waterman.
Harrison says the advertising was deemed misleading purely because it did not include a proviso or caveat stating that the figure related only to those accountants who actually recommend accounting software. "However, the campaign ran for over a year, so we will not be reworking these advertisements. We are now working on a new campaign."

